Replay shows DeVonta Smith's epic catch on 4th down should have been overturned in NFC championship game

Author Photo
DeVonta Smith-121121-GETTY-FTR

What an (almost) catch.

In the first quarter of the Eagles-49ers NFC championship game, Philly wideout DeVonta Smith made one of the best grabs of the entire 2023 NFL season. He came down with a one-handed, fourth-down grab that set Philadelphia for their first touchdown of the game.

It was the sort of highlight reel stuff that hit the Twittersphere quickly, but there is a catch — it actually wasn't a catch.

MORE: Who is the 49ers backup quarterback?

It took a bit for Fox to get to a replay, and a clear one at that, but a replay shown well after the fact did, indeed, confirm that the ball hit the ground.

That certainly explains Smith signaling to hurry up, to try and get a snap off to disallow the 49ers from challenging the play. It just about worked: Kyle Shanahnn decided not to challenge the play, and the Eagles would score soon after.

Things would spiral a bit for San Francisco soon after the Eagles touchdown. Brock Purdy would fumble on the ensuing possession, and also get injured on the play, leading to journeyman backup Josh Johnson entering the game.

It certainly was an eventful first quarter, if nothing else.

Author(s)
Joe Rivera Photo

Joe Rivera is a senior content producer at The Sporting News and teaches Multimedia Sports Reporting at his alma mater, Rutgers University.