Orange County DA explains decision not to charge driver in crash that killed paramedic

Orange County District Attorney Dave Hoovler says responding police reported that Pablo Colector failed a field sobriety test and allegedly smelled of alcohol, but that tests taken at the scene turned up negative for drugs and alcohol.

Blaise Gomez

Jan 26, 2023, 8:17 PM

Updated 476 days ago

Share:

Loved ones wanted justice after Lisa Sillins was killed crossing Robinson Avenue in the city of Newburgh last month.
The Ambulunz paramedic was walking to her car after a shift when police said she was hit by a drunk driver. But on Wednesday, prosecutors revealed a much different version of events.
“The toxicology report shows no illicit drugs, no prescription drugs, and no alcohol," said Orange County District Attorney Dave Hoovler. "This has to be classified as an accident.” 
Hoovler says responding police reported that Pablo Colector failed a field sobriety test and allegedly smelled of alcohol, but that tests taken at the scene turned up negative for drugs and alcohol. 
“I understand how police reached those conclusions but obviously, the toxicology reports, scientific evidence goes against that," said Hoovler.
Prosecutors say surveillance video shows the White Plains man wasn’t speeding on Route 9W or driving erratically before the tragedy and because of the findings, Colector can't be charged or ticketed with any wrongdoing. 
“People are very upset. Obviously, it’s hard to put those feelings down where you can think rationally," said Ashley Lurie, EMSPAC Hudson Valley Division Leader.
EMSPAC is an advocacy group that represents emergency medical technicians and supports their families - in this case, Sillins' mom, Ingrid. 
“She is devastated and reeling," said Lurie. "Any kind of headway in this case would have been something for her. So, to not have that is certainly difficult.” 
Lurie says friends and colleagues are now focusing their efforts to get a crosswalk installed and other safety upgrades put in at the intersection where Sillins was struck. 
Advocates plan to protest at the corner of Robinson Avenue and North Street on the day Sillins died each month until a safety study is done and upgrades at the intersection are made. 
An online fundraiser is hoping to help the paramedic's family.



More from News 12
0:24
Police: Hempstead man exposed, touched himself inappropriately at Roosevelt Field Mall

Police: Hempstead man exposed, touched himself inappropriately at Roosevelt Field Mall

2:48
Mostly cloudy skies with highs in the 70s today; chance of showers for the weekend

Mostly cloudy skies with highs in the 70s today; chance of showers for the weekend

2:25
Museum of American Armor hosting 10th anniversary of World War II Encampment weekend

Museum of American Armor hosting 10th anniversary of World War II Encampment weekend

0:24
Police: 2 men arrested for stealing copper wire, burglarizing Jericho business

Police: 2 men arrested for stealing copper wire, burglarizing Jericho business

0:23
FDA approves first self-test for cervical cancer

FDA approves first self-test for cervical cancer

1:08
East End: Kick off party to the summer showcasing the beauty of the region

East End: Kick off party to the summer showcasing the beauty of the region

1:07
The East End: Calissa in Water Mill

The East End: Calissa in Water Mill

1:36
The Real Deal: How to navigate the buying, renting market in New York

The Real Deal: How to navigate the buying, renting market in New York

2:07
Nassau County doctor convicted of illegally prescribing around 93,000 mg of oxycodone to 1 patient

Nassau County doctor convicted of illegally prescribing around 93,000 mg of oxycodone to 1 patient

1:44
Massapequa couple latest to be charged in connection with Jan. 6 Capitol riot

Massapequa couple latest to be charged in connection with Jan. 6 Capitol riot

0:30
 Police: Deer Park teen charged after making threats, bringing BB gun to Frost Middle School

Police: Deer Park teen charged after making threats, bringing BB gun to Frost Middle School

0:23
New York Rangers beat Carolina Hurricanes 5-3 to advance to Eastern Conference Final

New York Rangers beat Carolina Hurricanes 5-3 to advance to Eastern Conference Final

2:11
Commack man takes stand in civil trial claiming he was strip-searched by Suffolk police

Commack man takes stand in civil trial claiming he was strip-searched by Suffolk police

1:40
Blood drive held in honor of former Patchogue fire chief exceeds expectations

Blood drive held in honor of former Patchogue fire chief exceeds expectations

1:39
Long Islanders take part in No Mow May to help lawns flourish, aid early season pollinators

Long Islanders take part in No Mow May to help lawns flourish, aid early season pollinators

2:04
Food Pantry on NCC campus sees surge following shutdown of cafeteria

Food Pantry on NCC campus sees surge following shutdown of cafeteria

0:39
Suffolk Water Authority urges water conservation ahead of summer months

Suffolk Water Authority urges water conservation ahead of summer months

2:20
Suffolk police: 17 people arrested in one week during Operation Smoke Out

Suffolk police: 17 people arrested in one week during Operation Smoke Out

0:30
New screening can identify preeclampsia risk sooner in pregnancy

New screening can identify preeclampsia risk sooner in pregnancy

4:12
The East End: Explore the North Fork on 2 wheels via East End Bike Tours

The East End: Explore the North Fork on 2 wheels via East End Bike Tours