As if things couldn’t get any messier.
Before T.J. Holmes started a relationship with his “GMA 3” co-anchor Amy Robach, he had a three-year affair with married “Good Morning America” producer Natasha Singh that started in 2016.
Multiple sources told Page Six the cheating duo confided in Robach about their infidelity.
“Amy was the person they went to talk to about their affair and marriages,” an insider claimed.
Another source disputed that Robach was their confidante and insisted “she didn’t know about the affair until it was in its final stages. They told her about it right at the end.”
Their affair started off long-distance with Holmes based in New York and Singh working as a producer for the show from Los Angeles.
Holmes was just a “GMA” correspondent at the time and we’re told they’d meet up for romps during his travels.
Singh, who is also a yoga teacher and mediator, left the show in 2018 and moved to New York, where she started working as a producer for “CBS Mornings.” That’s when she and Holmes started spending even more time together.
“She fell in love with him. He had a key to her apartment,” another insider told us.
Singh told us “no comment” when we reached out.
Holmes’ wife, Marilee Fiebig, found out about the affair in 2019 after discovering several emails, we’re told.
And as rumors swirled about Holmes and Robach, “Marilee never considered Amy because she was focused on Natasha. She never thought about [him cheating] with Amy because they were friends. Amy’s daughter was their daughter’s baby-sitter,” the first source said.
Holmes ended the affair and the couple started working to reconcile their marriage throughout the pandemic.
Robach, however, remained friends with Singh and it angered Fiebig because “she would see photos of them on Instagram and she didn’t understand how their friend and her husband’s co-host could remain friends with the woman who tried to break up their marriage,” the third source said.
Singh’s friendship with Robach, however, soured earlier this year “around spring because [Amy] was so close to TJ,” they added.
It wasn’t until the summer that Fiebig grew suspicious of Robach because they started seeming “closer than colleagues.” Multiple sources told us Holmes and Robach would have random meetings during the day and hit the pub to have drinks with each other.
Still, Holmes and his wife “were fully together” in August and even celebrated his birthday with a trip to the Bahamas.
It was there that Fiebig discovered a birthday card from Robach that was too personal and “it brought back the old Natasha drama. She couldn’t trust him anymore,” the third source said.
Reps for the “GMA” couple and Fiebig did not comment.
Additional reporting by Mara Seigler
