Skip to content
NOWCAST NewsCenter 5 at 6
Watch on Demand
Advertisement

South Boston man takes the stand, says Whitey Bulger threatened him over Braintree murder

Fred Weichel spent 35 years in prison for a murder he insists he did not commit

South Boston man takes the stand, says Whitey Bulger threatened him over Braintree murder

Fred Weichel spent 35 years in prison for a murder he insists he did not commit

PRISON FOR A MURDER HE AND SAYS HE DID NOT COMMIT IS FIGHTING FOR COMPENSATION FROM THE STATE. MARIA: FIVE INVESTIGATES HAS BEEN FOLLOWING THE LEGAL ORDEAL FOR YEARS AND WAS IN COURT FOR THE START OF THE CIVIL SUIT AGAINST THE STATE. I UNDERSTAND WHITEY BULGER WAS IN THE SPOTLIGHT TODAY. >> WE DID HEAR ABOUT MULTIPLE CONVERSATIONS. FRED WHITEY -- FRED SAID HE HAD WITH WHITEY BULGER AND HOW HE FEARED HE WAS GOING TO TELL HIM. HIS TEAM SAYS THEIR CLIENT DESERVES TO BE COMPENSATED FOR THE NEARLY 36 YEARS HE SPENT IN PRISON BUT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL’S OFFICE SAYS NOT SO FAST. OPENING STATEMENTS IN THE CIVIL LAWSUIT FILED AGAINST THE STATE. HE IS ASKING FOR $1 MILLION IN SOCIAL CURSOR IN 2017 AFTER A POLICE REPORT NEVER HANDED OVER SURFACED SUGGESTING SOMEONE ELSE COULD HAVE COMMITTED THE CRIME. >> FRED WAS INNOCENT WHEN HE WENT TO PRISON. FOR 35 YEARS, EIGHT PLUS MONTHS, HE HAD TO LIVE IN SMALL CELL EVERY DAY KNOWING HE WAS AN INNOCENT MAN. >> THE FACT A JUDGE ORDERED A NEW CRIMINAL TRIAL DOES NOT MEAN HE IS INNOCENT. >>>> THE ATTORNEY GENERAL’S OFFICE IS SUGGESTING HE HELPED THE REAL KILLER AFTER THE CRIME WAS COMMITTED. HIS FRIEND CONFESSED TO THE MURDER IN A 1982 LETTER TO HIS MOTHER BUT WAS NEVER CHARGED WITH THE CRIME. >> WE WILL ALSO DECIDE WHETHER IN YOUR MINDS HE HAS PROVED HIMSELF INNOCENT OF THESE OTHER FELONY CRIMES BASED ON THE EVIDENCE YOU HEAR ABOUT HOW HE HELPED TOMMY BARRETT WE THE STATE WHEN POLICE WERE FOR. >> HE ADMITS CONNECTING BARRETT WITH A FRIEND IN CALIFORNIA BECAUSE BARRETT WAS IN TROUBLE. HE INSISTS THAT TROUBLE HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THE LAMONICA MURDER. HERE IS WHERE WHITEY BULGER COMES IN AND THE STORY GETS MURKY. >> IF YOU EVER MENTION TOMMY BARRETT’S NAME, I WILL KILL YOU IF I CAN’T GET YOU. , I WILL GET YOUR MOTHER, BROTHER AND SISTER. >> HE SAYS WHITEY BULGER VISITED HIM MULTIPLE TIMES BEFORE AND AFTER HE WAS ARRESTED WITH A WARNING. >> HE WAS GOING TO CUT MY HEAD OFF AND KICK IT DOWN THE STREET LIKE A HEAD OF LETTUCE. >> DID HE SAY ANYTHING ELSE TO YOU? >> NOT TO EVER MENTION TOMMY BARRETT’S NAME EVER. >> AS YOU CAN SEE, THE JURY IS GOING TO HAVE A LOT TO SORT THROUGH. HE IS IN THE MIDDLE OF HIS TESTIMONY. HE WILL CONTINUE HIS CROSS-EXAMINATION BY THE ATTORNEY GEN
Advertisement
South Boston man takes the stand, says Whitey Bulger threatened him over Braintree murder

Fred Weichel spent 35 years in prison for a murder he insists he did not commit

Fred Weichel took the stand today in his civil trial, asking for $1 million in compensation from the state for serving nearly four decades in prison for the 1980 murder of Robert Lamonica in Braintree.Weichel was released in 2017 after a police report that was never handed over surfaced, suggesting someone else could have committed the crime. Weichel was 28 when he was arrested. Now, he's 70."Fred was innocent when he went to prison. And for 35 years, 8 plus months, he had to live in a small cell. Every day knowing that he was an innocent man," said attorney Mark Loevy-Reyes, an attorney for Weichel.But lawyers for the Attorney General's office, who represent the state, said essentially not so fast, arguing that if Weichel didn't murder Lamonica, he helped the real killer after the crime was committed."The fact that a judge ordered a new criminal trial for Mr. Weichel, doesn't mean he's innocent. The fact that the district attorney made the decision not to re-prosecute him 40 years later, doesn't mean he's innocent," said assistant attorney general Abigail Fee.Today was the first day of testimony in Weichel's civil suit. Weichel's cross-examination is scheduled to continue on Tuesday.Weichel's friend, Tommy Barrett, later confessed to the murder in a 1982 letter to Weichel's mother, but was never charged with the crime."You will also decide whether in your minds he has proved himself innocent of these other felony crimes based on the evidence you hear. In particular, about how Mr. Weichel helped Tommy Barrett leave the state when police were looking for him," Fee said.Weichel admits connecting Barrett with a friend in California because Weichel says Barrett was in trouble. But Weichel insists that trouble had nothing to do with the Lamonica murder.On the stand, Weichel said he was ordered to keep Barrett's name out of the Lamonica investigation by South Boston mob boss James "Whitey" Bulger.Weichel testified that Whitey told him: "'If you ever mention Tommy Barrett's name I'll kill you. And if I can't get you, I'll get your mother, brother and sister.'"Weichel says Bulger visited multiple times before and after Weichel was arrested and issued warnings."He was going to cut my head off and kick it down the street like a head of lettuce," he said."Did he say anything else to you?" his lawyer asked."Not to mention Tommy Barrett's name. Ever," Weichel replied.

Fred Weichel took the stand today in his civil trial, asking for $1 million in compensation from the state for serving nearly four decades in prison for the 1980 murder of Robert Lamonica in Braintree.

Weichel was released in 2017 after a police report that was never handed over surfaced, suggesting someone else could have committed the crime. Weichel was 28 when he was arrested. Now, he's 70.

Advertisement

"Fred was innocent when he went to prison. And for 35 years, 8 plus months, he had to live in a small cell. Every day knowing that he was an innocent man," said attorney Mark Loevy-Reyes, an attorney for Weichel.

But lawyers for the Attorney General's office, who represent the state, said essentially not so fast, arguing that if Weichel didn't murder Lamonica, he helped the real killer after the crime was committed.

"The fact that a judge ordered a new criminal trial for Mr. Weichel, doesn't mean he's innocent. The fact that the district attorney made the decision not to re-prosecute him 40 years later, doesn't mean he's innocent," said assistant attorney general Abigail Fee.

fred weichel takes the stand in his civil lawsuit on monday.
Fred Weichel
Fred Weichel as a young man in South Boston.

Today was the first day of testimony in Weichel's civil suit. Weichel's cross-examination is scheduled to continue on Tuesday.

Weichel's friend, Tommy Barrett, later confessed to the murder in a 1982 letter to Weichel's mother, but was never charged with the crime.

"You will also decide whether in your minds he has proved himself innocent of these other felony crimes based on the evidence you hear. In particular, about how Mr. Weichel helped Tommy Barrett leave the state when police were looking for him," Fee said.

Weichel admits connecting Barrett with a friend in California because Weichel says Barrett was in trouble. But Weichel insists that trouble had nothing to do with the Lamonica murder.

fred weichel takes the stand in his civil lawsuit on monday.
WCVB
Tommy Barrett, seen in 2017, told Robert Lamonica’s mother that he was responsible for Lamonica’s murder, though he has never been charged with the crime.

On the stand, Weichel said he was ordered to keep Barrett's name out of the Lamonica investigation by South Boston mob boss James "Whitey" Bulger.

Weichel testified that Whitey told him: "'If you ever mention Tommy Barrett's name I'll kill you. And if I can't get you, I'll get your mother, brother and sister.'"

Fred Weichel testified Monday that James "Whitey" Bulger, pictured, threatened him over the murder of Robert Lamonica.
WCVB
Fred Weichel testified Monday that James "Whitey" Bulger, pictured, threatened him over the murder of Robert Lamonica.

Weichel says Bulger visited multiple times before and after Weichel was arrested and issued warnings.

"He was going to cut my head off and kick it down the street like a head of lettuce," he said.

"Did he say anything else to you?" his lawyer asked.

"Not to mention Tommy Barrett's name. Ever," Weichel replied.