Home› Strictly Come Dancing
Click here to check out Digital Spy's Strictly Come Dancing 2024 coverage, including breaking news and rumours for contestants, judges and professionals.

Which judge got the order (closest to) right? (Week 1, 2022)

TrumblesTrumbles Posts: 7,781
Forum Member
✭
in Strictly Come Dancing #1
I thought it might be worth resurrecting these polls
As always I haven't shown the actual scores the judges gave, just their effective ranking of the dances.
(Also no, I'm never going to include a 'none' option.)

All the judges used the same number of paddles which is unusual. Although on some points there was general agreement – Will and Hamza were good; Tony really wasn't – there were noticeable differences. See Kym and Jayde's positioning and where Craig put Kaye compared to the others.

Which judge got the order closest to right iyo?

Craig
1st Will, Hamza
2nd Molly, Fleur
3rd Kaye, James, Helen, Ellie S, Ellie T
4th Richie, Matt
5th Kym, Tyler, Jayde
6th Tony

Motsi
1st Will, Hamza
2nd Molly
3rd Jayde, Helen, Ellie S, Ellie T, Fleur
4th Kym
5th Tyler, Kaye, James, Richie, Matt
6th Tony

Shirley
1st Hamza
2nd Molly, Will
3rd Tyler, Ellie S, Ellie T, Fleur
4th Kym, Jayde, Richie, Helen
5th Kaye, James, Matt
6th Tony

Anton
1st Will
2nd Molly, Ellie T, Hamza, Fleur
3rd Kym, Richie, Helen
4th Tyler, Jayde, James, Ellie S
5th Kaye, Matt
6th Tony

Which judge got the order (closest to) right? (Week 1, 2022) 62 votes

Craig
29%
Brekkie21stCenturyBoySandsssSkyrahjerefprdterraricinusdoctorwhofancaldancing.queenSamantha_IsaacsChief_WiggumChristine DaaeJamesLav25PianoJaxKatieLovesDogsDutchDancingFanlaceydawsondanteWChrisD 18 votes
Motsi
20%
SelenadaisylaneMonksealperdiedumplingcazza1969Hannah49ChickenFromKievDervlathedogspannerannaReysNYGirlAragornetteScottie 13 votes
Shirley
17%
TelcontaryohinnchildemmageeringCatherineGTdavegoldMrs Checksjayne pasha fancaptain_cherubLoorienjenni490jadebry 11 votes
Anton
32%
sunshinebandTrumblescathh70CadivahannahjordanjohnsonBadWigeonJ.RMonsieur23Natalie_ShepardStrideKirbsterellaAtlasStonesOuatFan96AndyJWSSouthcoastrebelGlitterboxRJBRJBauntbabestrifleRosaMac2 20 votes

Comments

  • megashoppermegashopper Posts: 6,221
    Forum Member
    ✭
    #2
    Looking at the order of the results (many thanks) it doesn't look as bonkers as it seemed on the night. I'm quite happy with that but thought both Ellie T and Fleur were undermarked.
  • ReysReys Posts: 3,939
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    #3
    Motsi
    I can’t believe I’m going to say it but looking back at that I think Motsi had it virtually bang on with her scoring (or at least placements!)

    The others to me are all out of skew. Granted Motsi can completely go off tangent with her comments but considering her scoring looks about right she must be the judge who hasn’t lost her marbles yet! 😂
  • MonksealMonkseal Posts: 12,016
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    #4
    Motsi
    Other than Jayde being a bit high, Motsi's looks the closest to my own opinions on the whole as well.
  • Samantha_IsaacsSamantha_Isaacs Posts: 195,332
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    #5
    Craig
    .....
  • TrumblesTrumbles Posts: 7,781
    Forum Member
    ✭
    #6
    Anton
    megashopper wrote: »
    Looking at the order of the results (many thanks) it doesn't look as bonkers as it seemed on the night. I'm quite happy with that but thought both Ellie T and Fleur were undermarked.
    Yes I think we have to count any week on which the worst that can be said about the scores is that they're 'a bit odd' rather than 'wildly insane' as a win.
  • Mrs ChecksMrs Checks Posts: 8,372
    Forum Member
    ✭
    edited 29/09/22 - 13:41 #7
    Shirley
    Shirley got it closest to correct for me, but I would have swapped Tyler and Helen and downgraded Jayde by one point.

    Edit: actually I change my answer to Motsi, looking again! Her having Jayde so high put me off, but change that and she’s about right.

Sign In or Register to comment.