On the September 26 episode of Below Deck Mediterranean, Storm Smith shocked Natalya Scudder when he gave her a beautiful gold watch. Although she “loved it,” Natalya admitted in an interview that the gift made her think her relationship with Storm was “getting intense too soon.”

When Natalya appeared on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen the same night, naturally, the host wanted to know, “Do you still have the watch Storm gave you?”

“I actually have it in my bag. So, yes, I have it,” Natalya said. “I wear it sometimes, depending on the outfit. But I can’t actually read the time.”

During the Below Deck Med episode, Storm also caught Natalya off guard when he declared, “I’ll get your name tattooed… It’s happening tonight,” and quipped, “I’m getting Mzi [“Zee” Dempers] as well. Don’t think you’re special.” Although she said the gesture was “too much” at the time, Natalya feels differently about the moment today.  

“It was absolutely thrilling,” Natalya told Andy on WWHL. “I was very excited.” As for whether Storm ever ended up getting that tattoo, Natalya teased, “You never know, maybe he will get one at the end of the season, we don’t know yet. Maybe I have a tattoo of Storm somewhere.”

Press play on the video above to see more of Natalya on WWHL!

Watch Below Deck Med on Bravo Mondays at 8/7c and on the Bravo app. Catch new episodes one week early on Peacock.