Hearing will determine whether Lancaster County teen accused of killing sister should be tried as adult
A hearing began Monday in Lancaster County to determine whether a teenager accused of stabbing her sister to death should be tried as an adult or a juvenile.
Homicide is automatically treated as an adult crime in Pennsylvania. Claire Miller was 14 when she was charged.
Police said Miller admitted to fatally stabbing her 19-year-old sister, Helen, in February 2021 in their Manheim Township home. Helen Miller had cerebral palsy and was wheelchair-bound.
Note: Some viewers may find the details described in court to be graphic.
The hearing included emotional testimony from Miller's parents. Her mother, Marie, choked back tears several times, saying she didn’t want to lose another child.
Marie Miller told the court, "We love both of them. I know Claire did not mean to do this. We lost Helen and we don't want to lose Claire too. We don't want her to be punished, not get help and be put away for a long period for something that was out of her control. We can't lose her too."
Marie Miller talked about how Claire Miller had changed, transforming from a happy child and excellent student who won a citizenship award to someone filled with anxiety who committed self-mutilation by cutting her legs.
But Marie Miller said her daughter cared for her older sister.
"Helen had times she was in pain. Claire did all she could to help Helen feel better," Marie Miller said.
The defense called two psychologists, who testified Claire Miller suffered from depression, anxiety disorder and psychosis. The psychologists said Miller told them she suffered hallucinations, with voices that led her to try and slash her own throat the night her sister died.
But prosecutors brought up text messages indicating Miller sought to harm others.
The defense is arguing Miller can be rehabilitated.
The hearing will continue Tuesday.