Missing 21-year-old is found buried in a Missouri barn after leaving home with her uncle and his girlfriend

  • The body of Jessi Wilfong, 21, was found buried in a Missouri barn on June 18
  • Wilfong was reported missing by her mom, Kathy, on May 25 
  • Remains of the missing woman were found in a barn nearby the home of her uncle's girlfriend 
  • Teresa L. Baumgartner, 59, was arrested in connection with the crime and charged with tampering of physical evidence in a felony investigation

A 21-year-old woman who disappeared in May was found buried in a Missouri barn.

Jessi Wilfong was reported missing by her mother, Kathy Wilfong, on May 25 - nearly a week after she last saw her daughter at her Millersville residence on May 19.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jessi allegedly met up with her uncle, Lawrence Schanda, and his girlfriend, Teresa L. Baumgartner, 59, on the evening she was last seen by her mom, Kathy revealed on The Lawless Files podcast.

Surveillance footage from a neighbor captured Jessi arriving at her uncle's home and never leaving, according to her mother.

Jessi's phone died the night she went missing, Kathy said. As time passed, she knew something was wrong when her daughter didn't update her social media platforms, which she found 'weird.'

Wilfong was captured on surveillance footage arriving at her uncle's home and never leaving, according to her mom.
Wilfong's phone died the night of May 19 and wasn't heard from again, her mom claimed.
Kathy alleges her daughter was never seen coming out of Lawrence Schanda and Baumgartner's (left) home
Teresa L. Baumgartner, 59, was arrested and charged with tampering with physical evidence in connection with Wilfong's disappearance

According to a probable-cause statement filed by Det. Jaime Holloway, undisclosed information led investigators at Cape Girardeau County Sheriff's Office to a residence in the county belonging to Baumgartner and Schanda on June 15, The Southeast Missourian reported. 

At the home investigators found that carpet from the living room had been removed, KFVS News reported.

'From the evidence collected and other information obtained from the investigative process, it was suspected that foul play was involved in the disappearance of Ms. Wilfong,' Sheriff Ruth Ann Dickerson wrote in a news release

On June 18, deputies were led to a barn 'in close proximity' to the residence of Baumgartner. Investigators found a portion of the ground recently tampered - where Jessi's remains were later discovered. 

Her death was ruled a homicide two days later. 

Baumgartner was arrested on June 21 in connection with Jessi's disappearance and charged with tampering with physical evidence in a felony investigation. An auger rented by Baumgartner of May 24 was found in the barn. 

Schanda, meanwhile, hasn't been arrested or charged in connection with the case. He did, however, tell officers on June 8 that he had gotten into a verbal altercation with his niece on May 19 after she allegedly provided law enforcement with information about his illegal drug activity. 

ADVERTISEMENT

The investigation is ongoing.  

Most Read News

Rampaging Household Cavalry horses 'spooked by builders moving concrete': Noise caused animals on...

Pictured: Teacher who was stabbed with colleague and pupil in 'butterfly knife' attack in secondary...

Ammanford school 'stabbing': 'Schoolgirl' is arrested after three people 'including female teacher'...

Woman, 21, is left fighting for life after drinking coffee filled with INSECTS which she bought from...

Moment escaped Household Cavalry horse 'spooked by builders' is finally captured: Bleeding animal...

Princess Beatrice's ex-boyfriend is found dead 'of overdose' in Miami hotel room 'after running up...

Horse trainer, 36, accused of raping and murdering female showjumper, 21, is found dead at his home...

What WAS wrong with the Household Cavalry's horses yesterday? New video shows animals spooked - with...

Schoolteacher stabbed in the neck 'lucky to be alive' after she was targeted in playground attack...

Princess Beatrice 'heartbroken' after 'playboy' ex Paolo Liuzzi is found dead in suspected overdose...

Pictured: Hero teacher who bravely disarmed girl 'going mad' with a knife by putting her into an...

Two 'seriously' injured runaway Household Cavalry horses undergo operations and are being 'closely...

Horse seen badly hurt among Household Cavalry animals who bolted through London after being spooked...

Angela Rayner brands Rishi Sunak 'a pint-sized loser' as she tries to bat away PMQs jibes about two...

Pensioners refuse to leave their park homes despite council ruling they only have permission to stay...

Village held hostage by feral teenage girls calls in private security to patrol the streets as their...