‘We’re still here’: Syracuse activists pledge to continue fight to remove Christopher Columbus statue

The Columbus Monument, in Columbus Circle was designed by the Syracuse-born architect, Dwight James Baum in 1934. This circle is one of the most popular places in Syracuse for gathering and sitting. It is surrounded by the Roman Catholic Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception, the County Court House and the County's John H. Mulroy Civic Center.

We’ll deliver breaking news directly to your inbox. Sign up today.

Standing in the shadow of the statue of they have spent years trying to remove, activists gathered Monday evening in Columbus Circle in downtown Syracuse.

They carried signs that distilled their cause in simple words: “Celebrate Diversity, Remove Columbus,” “Teach our history” and “Honor Indigenous people.”

The demonstration followed a ruling by a state judge that blocked Mayor Ben Walsh from removing the statue in response to criticisms that Columbus contributed to slavery and oppression. Walsh exceeded his authority by deciding to remove the statue without approval from the Common Council, the judge ruled.

State Supreme Court Judge Gerard Neri also pointed to the city’s obligation to maintain the monument, after accepting state and private money in 1992 to restore the statue.

As the city moves forward with an appeal, activists pledged Monday to take their fight to remove the nearly 90-year-old monument to the Common Council.

For those opposed to the statue, the likeness of Christopher Columbus represents a man and era that disparaged the rights, land, and human rights of Indigenous people.

“We don’t want to look up when we come downtown with our kids and see this man,” Onondaga activist Danielle Smith told the assembled crowd Monday evening.

“We can’t give up this fight. Even though it is frustrating and trying, we have to keep showing up.”

“We all respect the legacy of our ancestors, we are obligated to honor historical truths, not myths or made up scenarios,” said Natalie LoRusso of Women of Italian and Syracuse Heritage, or WISH. “This 1934 monument of Christopher Columbus is no longer a suitable symbol of pride.”

In October 2020, Walsh announced his plan to remove the Columbus statue from the circle and redevelop the site into a heritage park that honored Italian-Americans as well as the contributions of Native Americans and other traditionally marginalized groups.

The decision came after two years of discussion by a committee Walsh appointed to discuss the issue, which included scholars, historians, Haudenosaunee leaders and Italian-Americans.

“We all came together and we had these conversations, these really tough conversations that were uncomfortable,” said Smith, who participated as part of the Resilient Indigenous Action Collective. “But we sat through it, because we saw that it needed to change. The only way change happens is when people talk to each other.”

The statue was erected in 1934, paid for by a fundraising campaign by local Italian-American immigrants who saw the statue as an expression of pride for their native country in their new home city.

It has come under scrutiny in recent years as the legacy of Christopher Columbus has been revisited. Community activists and many Native Americans argue the statue celebrates a man who was barbaric in his treatment of indigenous people and responsible for enslavement and genocide.

“That was a different time - this is 2022, there’s no excuse,” Smith said, standing behind a sign that read, “Columbus didn’t discover anything: 1000s of Native nations were already here.”

“You know better, so do better,” she continued. “To me, it is mind-blowing that some people still defend this man.”

Smith pointed to other communities that have removed statues that memorialize historical figures such as Confederate generals. Since 2020, dozens of statues of Columbus have been taken down or are in the process of being removed across the United States.

“Syracuse is behind,” she said. “We can’t stay stuck in the past.”

Organizers said their next step would be sharing their concerns with members of the Common Council and asking them to take a stance on the issue.

“We’re still here,” Smith said. “We’re not going anywhere. We’re going to keep fighting. “We have to remember that all of our actions and decisions are impacting that those that come behind us.”

Neighbors of the Onondaga Nation (NOON) and Women of Italian and Syracuse Heritage (WISH) will host a virtual seminar discussing the political value of erecting and removing statues on Thursday, March 24.

READ MORE

Syracuse Mayor Ben Walsh can’t remove downtown Christopher Columbus statue, judge rules

Walsh to remove Syracuse’s Columbus statue, rename downtown circle

In Syracuse, the fight over a monument clouds Columbus Day events

Syracuse’s Columbus statue debate: Why we should remove it and why we should keep it (video)

If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

X

Opt out of the sale or sharing of personal information

If you opt out, we won’t sell or share your personal information to inform the ads you see. You may still see interest-based ads if your information is sold or shared by other companies or was sold or shared previously.