Who Will Replace Chris Cuomo? Even CNN Doesn’t Seem Sure (Yet)
Some staffers at the WarnerMedia network believe CNN has been holding the equivalent of on-air tryouts in recent weeks, turning over the 9 p.m. hour to hosts like Michael Smerconish, Laura Coates and Brianna Keilar . Jim Acosta , the former White House reporter turned weekend anchor, takes a turn this week. Both he and Keilar have held forth under the program banner, “Democracy in Peril,” a show that. at least in its early hours, a little like Ted Koppel’s “Nightline.” “We are taking a closer look at the state of our country, the threats to our political system and possible solutions for reversing the divisiveness that is tearing America apart,” said Keilar, indicating CNN wants to continue its recent emphasis on probing the aftermath of the January 6 insurrection of last year.
CNN declined to make executives available for comment. The slot has been open since CNN canceled “Cuomo Prime Time” in late November after the anchor was suspended and then fired for helping his brother, former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo, while he was accused of sexual harassment, leading him to step down from his role. The older Cuomo has denied the claims. One person familiar with the network said executives were examining programming at 9 p.m. “week by week.”
But there’s nothing casual about filling a prime-time cable-news slot , even in these days of intense focus on the possibilities of streaming . CNN has seen its viewership at 9 p.m. erode noticeably since Cuomo departed. In 2021, “Cuomo Prime Time” and other weeknight 9 p.m. shows fetched an average of 293,000 people between 25 and 54, the audience advertisers want most in news programming. Last week’s 9 p.m. shows, a mix of Keilar and Anderson Cooper, nabbed an average of 147,000, according to Nielsen — representing a drop of 49.8%.
The 9 o’clock hour has perhaps been the most powerful block for the past few years for cable-news advertisers, with Cuomo, Sean Hannity and Rachel Maddow all holding forth in the period. To be sure, 8 p.m. has long been important, built in the past on the backs of Bill O’Reilly and Keith Olbermann (and more recently, Tucker Carlson, though Madison Avenue’s relationship with his show has been strained .) A robust 9 p.m. hour, however, can push audiences into an evening-long relationship with a particular cable-news lineup, grabbing the 8 o’clock crowd for a little while longer and shoving them toward late-evening options at a time when more viewers are prone to seek out entertainment fare.
CNN has economic incentive to find someone with appeal. “Cuomo Prime Time” generated $47 million in advertising through November of last year, according to Standard Media Index, a tracker of ad spending. Fox News Channel’s “Hannity” captured $54.3 million during that period, while MSNBC’s “The Rachel Maddow Show” secured $45.5 million.
Audiences for Cuomo’s show were typically smaller than the crowds for both his competitors, but his work bolstered CNN’s standing on Madison Avenue. The average cost of a 30-second spot on “Cuomo” came to $7,400, compared to $11,500 for “Hannity” and $8,600 for “Maddow,” according to SMI. But only Cuomo’s ad price increased compared to the year-earlier period. The average cost of a 30-second ad for CNN’s 9 p.m. slot through November of last year rose 5%, according to SMI, compared to declines of 15% for “Maddow” and 10% for “Hannity.”
There has been much speculation that CNN might choose to hire an outsider to take on the slot. Brian Williams recently left NBC News after many years, and CBS News is believed to be in discussions with both Gayle King and Norah O’Donnell about renewing contracts set to lapse in coming months. Nabbing those anchors, however, might require more money than CNN, its parent WarnerMedia, or its soon-to-be new owner, Discovery, want to spend at a time when TV audiences are moving to new kinds of distribution.
Among the anchors who have filled the slot in recent weeks, Coates may have the closest link to CNN’s current primetime schedule. The former federal prosecutor has filled in for Don Lemon in the past, and, among observers, has long been seen as being in line for a possible nighttime show. Smerconish brings with him a natural audience, having worked at MSNBC. He currently hosts a show at SiriusXM. Keilar and Acosta have in recent years thrived at CNN by developing bare-knuckles dispositions that mirror the aggressive interviewing demeanor of the anchor who once led the slot in question.
CNN is relying on a strategy that its rivals have used in the recent past. Fox News saw its ratings grow while using a rotating array of conservative hosts at 7 p.m. over a year before deciding to give the slot to Jesse Watters. MSNBC held an on-air bake-off of sorts for Joy Reid’s weekend show before giving Saturdays to Tiffany Cross and Sundays to Jonathan Capehart.
And despite its interim ratings, CNN may have good reason to wait. In coming weeks, MSNBC is likely to reveal its plans for its own nighttime lineup. The network has been rotating different hosts in “11th Hour,” which was previously anchored by Brian Williams, and it is expected to have to fill times left by Rachel Maddow, who has signed a deal that will give her broader production duties at NBCU. CNN may not really know who to assign to the empty position until it knows who else will take to the playing field.