By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy. We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
And just like that, HBO on Monday transported us to The Gilded Age, another series starring Cynthia Nixon in which New York essentially plays a character all its own.
But this is a very different New York than the one inhabited by Miranda Hobbes. As the show’s title suggests, this is the New York of 1882, where no one is meeting at brunch to wax poetic about their sex lives. Heck, brunch won’t even become popular in America for another 50 years. As for the sex, don’t hold your breath. Even married couples post up in separate bedrooms at the end of the night.
In some ways, it’s more like The Real Housewives of Old New York, complete with the same basic takeaway: money can’t buy you class.
Money can, however, buy you a pretty exquisite set. “We couldn’t take over a street on the Upper East Side, or pretty much anywhere, for the period of time we’d need to turn it into,” executive producer David Crockett tells TVLine. “So we built a city-long backlot for the street scenes. Our production team built these palaces, which in present day only exist as museums and colleges and whatever.”
Read on for our breakdown of Monday’s premiere, along with more insight from the cast and EPs:
HELL HATH NO FURY | In this war of old money vs. new, Bertha Russell (Carrie Coon) and her husband George (Morgan Spector) represent new money with a capital-N. And a capital-M while we’re at it, because let me tell you, these hot monsters have money, honey. Adjusting for inflation, you could probably bottle one of the Russells’ farts and use it to pay off a semester of college tuition at any of the ivies today. But even with George’s impressive standing in the business sector (so much talk of trains!), the Russells remain shunned by the established upper crust. One society shrew even manages to shade the Russells’ lavish home — which, may I remind you, has its own Beauty and the Beast-style ballroom — by saying, “How brave not to go with the same old builders everyone else uses.” How brave, indeed.
Still, Bertha hopes to win over her potential frenemies with a lavish palace-warming party, only for those hopes to get dashed when [sad trombone] almost no one shows up. No one important, anyway. (No offense, Kelli O’Hara! I loved you in the Bridges of Madison County musical!) Even more painful than the sight of that empty house is the veritable smorgasbord of fine foodery that goes uneaten. But even as Bertha cries herself to sleep, her resilience remains. “I’ll never give up,” she tells her husband. “And I promise, I’ll make them sorry one day.”
On the subject of Bertha’s fabulous, feathered frocks, Coon acknowledges that the pandemic ultimately benefitted the show’s wardrobe. “Because of Covid, [the costuming team] actually got more time to do hand embroidery and hand beading. They got to to put even more detail than they otherwise would have because of the shutdown. In some ways, we benefited greatly from that time. We also kept all the Broadway shops open and all the Broadway actors employed. But it was extraordinary. I’ve never been costumed like that in my life.”
‘FOR A NEW YORKER, ANYTHING IS POSSIBLE’ | Now for the old money of it all: Just across the street from the Russells, we meet Agnes van Rhijn (Christine Baranski) and Ada Brook (Nixon), a pair of wildly different sisters. Just imagine Pinky and the Brain in wigs and petticoats and you’ll get a pretty good sense of their dynamic. Their life of peaceful snobbery is unexpectedly turned upside down when their niece Marian (Louisa Jacobson), the daughter of their estranged brother who misappropriated the family fortune, comes to live with them after her father’s death. On her journey from Pennsylvania to the Big Apple, Marian befriends an aspiring writer named Peggy (Denée Benton), who ultimately accepts a job offer from Agnes to work as her personal secretary.
For Benton, part of the excitement of playing Peggy comes with the opportunity to depict an affluent Black woman at this time. “We’re so used to this very down-trodden narrative about this person who’s suffering from all levels of abuse,” Benton says. “And while Peggy is suffering from some of those same abuses, we’re able to see the way most Black women move through that space. We make everything fly, no matter how much we’re given. For someone like Peggy, with access to money, I felt very strongly that she have access to similar types of finery that the white women have in the show.” The fact that her mother is played by Audra freaking McDonald is merely the icing on the cake.
And if you’re already swooning over the prospects of Marian and legal hottie Tom Raikes (Thomas Cocquerel), you’re not alone. “They’re both outsiders,” notes executive producer David Crockett. “They both come from a small town to the big city, which a lot of people can relate to. What’s interesting about their journey is that they start in a very similar place, but they react to the city in different ways. They’re both young and idealistic, and you learn a lot about our world through their eyes. You want them to thrive, and you’ll see where that goes.”
THE GILDED CLOSET | Though he presents himself as a man about town in pursuit of the perfect bride, Agnes’ son Oscar (Blake Ritson) is revealed to have a male lover at the end of Monday’s premiere. Is it entirely shocking? Not for anyone with functioning gaydar. But when you remember that this show takes place in 1882, Oscar’s secret does feel a bit more scandalous — and far more tragic.
“If you look back through history, as we did, you find examples of gay men and women that existed and were out, so to speak, with their homosexuality,” Crockett says. “That was not an issue for some, but for most, of course, it was kept in the shadows. Julian wanted to portray it because it was real life. Just like all of the people that you see in these stories, these are just people living their lives. They have the same issues that we have today.”
Adds EP Gareth Neame, “Oscar does really want a ‘normal’ life. He wants money and a comfortable lifestyle, but the only way for him to do that is to disguise his sexuality and form a marriage. Though it seems dishonest in some way, he’s serious about it. He remarks several times [in the first few episodes] that he can do this for a period of his life, but at some point he’ll need to settle down and marry into money, and he’s not going to live this lifestyle for the rest of his life. That was true of people almost within our lifetime, certainly up until the 1960s. It will be fascinating for younger audiences to see how extraordinarily different the morals of the time were.”
Your thoughts on The Gilded Age thus far? Grade the premiere below, then drop a comment with your full review.
So Oscar is schtuping John Adams, grandson of a president? First world problems, am I right?!
.
I’m happy to read that Mr. Raikes could return – I thought he and Marian had chemistry. As did she and Larry (?) Russell. Clear love triangle going to form there.
.
Overall I give the premiere a B+, but give the review an A+ for monetizing “bottled farts”. :)
I could definitely root for Marian and Tom the lawyer, but I could also see myself rooting for Marian and Larry. The sheer amount of drama and family reactions that the latter would elicit are just too good to not attempt it at some point.
B+
I think this will be an excellent series. The stories are written well and so much potential for along series.
Could be great, but there are too many casting missteps. Two well known actresses, who were hired to add some gravitas I suspect, are just not a good fit. Maybe their characters and portrayals will grow on me, I love the story, writing is witty, and most of the cast is enjoyable, so it’s a B+ for me. Just my opinion, please no nasty replies.
If you’re talking about Baranski and Nixon, those are the only two that WERE cast correctly. And I pray Coon pans out for me since it’s clearly a pivotal role.
Agree!!
It was really great! Can’t wait to watch more.
Why are they all so old, I wonder? Taissa Farmiga is 27 and meant to be playing a 16 year old, as best I can gather. Marian’s actress is 30 and clearly supposed to be around age 20. She’d be considered a spinster at 30 already in 1882. So why do we think Fellows cast older? Do we think he’s planning on time skips in the show’s future? Could be interesting.
The one exception is Carrie Coon, who’s 41 and playing the mother of a guy who just graduated from Harvard. I wonder how old her character was when he was born.
Don’t forget the era – it wasn’t uncommon for brides to be super young. The whole purpose of debutante balls and coming out was to put the young lady on display and to attract a husband – you heard that was the Aunts’ immediate goal for Marian, to find someone to marry. Let’s say Mrs. Russell was married at 19 or 20 – she could easily have a child graduating college at age 41.
Check out the ages of the cast of Grease who were supposed to be graduating high school.
Not sure why but Louisa Jacobson’s portrayal of her character just doesn’t sit well with me. I’m not sure why, but she doesn’t feel genuine. Stiffer than everyone else. ok, not great acting to put it bluntly. As for Nixon and Baranski they are fabulous actors so I’m expecting for their portrayal of their characters as written to grow on me.
I enjoyed everyone else pretty much and look forward to seeing what happens in the future, especially, of course the potential romantic triangle (hopefully Tom the lawyer shows up sooner than later). I also look forward to the day when Carrie Coon’s daughter stands up to her mother. Now the fallout from that would be interesting.
And I do look forward to seeing the “old” ladies being put in their place.
Contrary to the the review this past week of this show, I’m looking forward to the next episode.
I have to agree about Louisa Jacobson but I also don’t think she’s a very compelling character, regardless of who plays her. She doesn’t feel like someone I would root for and I find her to be somewhat entitled and “high and mighty”. The same could be said for others but they embrace their snobbery and are more engaging to watch. To be honest, I’d rather they reduce or remove that role and focus on the other more interesting storylines
The Broadway cred alone is worth watching. I hope they break out into a musical ep.
The entire show is dripping in Broadway talent. I spent my first watching just picking out the actors and actresses…. its exciting that they get such juicy roles and expect great things from this journey.
Amazing show.
The show was all good and interesting until the end when the gay love scene was thrown in. Totally off-putting. Uncharacteristically placed in there. You lost me! Bye!
So gay love is a relatively modern concept? I’m confused by this comment.
Shut up
Larry Russell looks like a young Lord Gillingham from DA.