This is the window of time when value can outperform growth in the stock market
Big Tech often hogs all the headlines.
But so far this year, large-cap value stocks — those that typically trade lower to book value and earnings and have slower growth rates — have been outperforming growth stocks.
The policy turnaround by the Federal Reserve toward stifling inflation has led to significant declines for many technology stocks that trade at high multiples to earnings.
But what might surprise you is that large-cap value stocks as a group are expected to increase earnings per share more quickly than growth stocks this year and for the two years through 2023. Those estimates are below.
Value’s time to shine?
Based on a multi-decade data analysis, John Buckingham, a value stock portfolio manager and editor of The Prudent Speculator newsletter, wrote in a note to clients on Jan. 17 that although stocks in general perform better when the Fed is cutting interest rates, “[v]alue has enjoyed terrific annualized returns, on average, when the Fed is tightening monetary policy.”
See this one-year chart through Jan. 14 showing total returns, with dividends reinvested, for the S&P 500 Index SPX and two overlapping subsets of the benchmark, the S&P 500 Growth Index and the S&P 500 Value Index:
The value group has been the up-and-comer so far in 2022. Also of note, the yield on 10-year U.S. Treasury notes has increased to 1.84% from 1.52% on Dec. 31 and 1.11% a year ago.
Buckingham wrote: “Value stocks have a long way to go just to make it back to equilibrium with their more richly valued peers.”
This 20-year total-return chart bears that out:
The S&P 500 Value Index has greatly underperformed the S&P 500 Growth Index and the full S&P 500 over the past 20 years, although growth’s outperformance has been most pronounced during the pandemic. The first chart indicates investors’ moods have been changing in favor of value recently, and the Fed’s new anti-inflation stance — its first since the 1980s — might underline a real multiyear run for value.
Another way to test Buckingham’s statement is to look at relative forward price-to-earnings multiples for exchange traded funds that track all three groups of large-cap stocks:
ETF Ticker Forward P/E 20-year average forward P/E Current valuation to 20-year average Current valuation to S&P 500 20-year average valuation to S&P 500
SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 Growth ETF SPYG 26.24 18.75 140% 127% 121%
SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 Value ETF SPYV 17.03 13.35 128% 82% 86%
SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust SPY 20.73 15.48 134%
All three groups of stocks trade high on a forward P/E basis, when compared to their 20-year averages. But the value group’s forward P/E hasn’t risen as much and it is still trading lower to the full S&P 500’s value than it has, on average, over the past two decades.
Quite a bit depends on your own opinion. If you expect interest rates to rise significantly over the next couple of years and for that to help lead to a real change in behavior among stock investors, it’s value’s time in the sun.
Value’s surprise earnings power
Investors rightfully expect growth stocks to increase sales and earnings more quickly than value stocks. Looking at weighted aggregate consensus estimates for the ETFs, as calculated by FactSet, analysts expect the growth group to increase sales more quickly, as usual. But look at the earnings-per-share estimates:
ETF Ticker Est. EPS – 2021 Est. EPS – 2022 Est. EPS – 2023 Est. EPS – 2024 Est. EPS increase – 2022 2-year Est. EPS CAGR
SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 Growth ETF SPYG $2.43 $2.61 $2.88 $3.23 7.4% 8.9%
SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 Value ETF SPYV $2.25 $2.49 $2.73 $2.92 10.7% 10.2%
SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust SPY $20.47 $22.34 $24.53 $27.00 9.1% 9.5%
The value group is expected to achieve the most rapid EPS increase this year, and to have the best two-year compound annual growth rate for EPS through 2023.
Value stock screen
S&P Dow Jones Indices breaks the full S&P 500 into two growth and value subsets that are about the same size when it comes to market capitalization, with about 34% of stocks falling into both groups, as described here.
There are 239 stocks in the S&P 500 Growth Index, and it is highly concentrated, with the five largest holdings of the SPDR S&P 500 Growth ETF making up nearly 44% of the portfolio. The biggest holding is Apple Inc AAPL, at 13.3%, followed by Microsoft Corp. MSFT, at 11.4%, then Alphabet Inc.’s Class A GOOGL and Class C GOOG shares at a combined 8%. Amazon.com Inc. AMZN is at 7%, and Tesla Inc. TSLA at 4.2%.
There are 449 stocks in the S&P 500 Value Index, and it is far less concentrated, with Berkshire Hathaway Inc. BRK the largest holding at 3.1% of the SPDR S&P 500 Value ETF portfolio and the top five names making up 10.3%.
Within the S&P 500 Value Index, these 20 stocks have the most implied upside potential, based on consensus price targets, among those rated “buy” or the equivalent by at least 75% of analysts polled by FactSet:
Company Ticker Share “buy” ratings Closing price – Jan. 14 Consensus price target Implied 12-month upside potential Also in S&P 500 Growth Index?
Bath & Body Works Inc. BBWI 85% $55.83 $90.39 62% Yes
Caesars Entertainment Inc. CZR 94% $82.84 $133.36 61% Yes
T-Mobile US Inc. TMUS 84% $108.52 $163.74 51% No
Catalent Inc. CTLT 93% $108.24 $160.42 48% Yes
PayPal Holdings Inc. PYPL 82% $178.42 $262.67 47% Yes
Bio-Rad Laboratories Inc. Class A BIO 83% $628.23 $918.75 46% Yes
Match Group Inc. MTCH 75% $121.15 $172.63 42% No
Salesforce.com Inc. CRM 84% $231.23 $328.18 42% Yes
News Corp. Class A NWSA 88% $22.72 $31.91 40% No
Alaska Air Group Inc. ALK 93% $55.79 $76.21 37% No
AES Corp. AES 92% $23.06 $30.55 32% No
Teledyne Technologies Inc. TDY 78% $420.48 $537.13 28% No
Quanta Services Inc. PWR 83% $106.64 $136.19 28% No
Laboratory Corp. of America Holdings LH 89% $276.08 $351.08 27% Yes
Assurant Inc. AIZ 100% $154.89 $194.17 25% No
Visa Inc. Class A V 86% $214.67 $269.08 25% Yes
Nike Inc. Class B NKE 75% $148.18 $185.45 25% Yes
General Motors Co. GM 80% $61.10 $75.88 24% No
IQVIA Holdings Inc. IQV 90% $247.34 $305.24 23% Yes
Synopsys Inc. SNPS 88% $326.16 $401.13 23% Yes
Click on the tickers for more about each company, including financials, estimates and corporate profiles.
Then read Tomi Kilgore’s detailed guide to the wealth of information available for free on the MarketWatch quote page
Note that 11 of the 20 are also included in the S&P 500 Growth Index, as indicated on the table.
News Corp. NWSA is the holding company of Dow Jones & Co., which owns MarketWatch.