Disney cruise vs. Disney World: Which is the more magical vacation?
If you're in the mood for a Disney vacation, it's natural for your first thought to go to one of the Disney theme parks, such as Disney World or Disneyland. But as someone who loves the Disney parks, I'm here to tell you that's not always the best Disney vacation. In fact, it's entirely possible that for some families — and some trips — the better Disney vacation is the one you'll find at sea on a Disney cruise.
So, which do you choose: a Disney cruise or Disney World?
There are pros and cons to each choice. Disney parks have gotten more expensive with an a la carte pricing model that no longer includes airport transfers, FastPasses and other nice-to-have conveniences. A theme park vacation can also be complicated to plan, especially if you haven't been to Disney in several years and aren't familiar with the current rules and ways to minimize wait times.
At the same time, some fantastic new rides have opened in the last few years. You also have your choice of dozens of resort hotels at different price points, and it's hard to beat that feeling of walking down Main Street, U.S.A. toward the castle.
Meanwhile, on a Disney cruise, things have mainly stayed the same as they have been for the past 25 years, with activities, entertainment, lodging and most of your dining included in one cruise price. And yes, Mickey and his friends are found on board, so you can still get that photo and hug with your favorite pal.
But while you'll find Mickey both on a Disney cruise and at Disney World, the two vacation experiences are quite different. Here's a look at a Disney cruise versus a trip to Disney World to help you decide which family vacation is better for you.
Related: Are the Disney Visa credit cards worth it?
Planning
Both a Disney cruise and a trip to Disney World are large financial investments, so both are going to require some level of planning to be sure you are getting the most from your dollars and time.
That said, in both cases, you can leave many of the arrangements to the Disney vacation planning professionals, who can walk you through what you really need to know and book the main components of the trip.
For Disney World, decisions to make include where to stay and which park tickets are best for you (after factoring in how many days you wish to visit, whether or not you want to park hop, etc.). You'll want to book your sit-down meals 60 days in advance and familiarize yourself with the Disney Genie+ system if you don't want to spend hours each day in line. Although things could change in 2024, right now, you can't select any of your Genie+ attractions in advance, so you'll be doing that on your trip.
For a Disney Cruise Line sailing, you'll have to decide if you prefer a newer or more classic ship, where you want to go, which port to sail from and how many days you wish to sail.
For example, you could sail out of Port Canaveral in Florida on Disney Wish for a three- or four-night sailing to the Bahamas, spend a week cruising around Alaska on Disney Wonder or sail in Europe on Disney Dream. At certain times of the year, you'll also find Disney Cruise Line sailings out of Texas, Louisiana and California.
Once you pick a sailing, ship and cabin, you don't actually have to plan anything in advance unless you want to book excursions in port. It's common to prebook shore tours for Europe and Alaska cruises, but on Bahamas sailings, many families simply head to the beach in port or enjoy being on the ship. For trips like that, minimal planning is required once you lock in the basics.
FOR NO-COST ASSISTANCE WITH PLANNING AND BOOKING YOUR NEXT DISNEY VACATION, CHECK OUT TPG'S DISNEY BOOKING PARTNER, MOUSE COUNSELORS.
With a Disney cruise, dinner each night at a pre-assigned sit-down restaurant is included in your fare, and you only need to select an early or late seating in advance. The buffet, room service and on-deck grab-and-go food are available for no extra charge during the day. You only have to plan out meals if you want a reservation at one of the adults-only restaurants on board.
Winner: Both a Disney cruise and a Disney World vacation require some advance planning. How much planning the cruise requires depends on the destination you select, so it might be more planning intensive than Disney World. However, some Disney cruises likely require less planning than the average Disney World vacation.
Related: A magical guide for how to plan a trip to Disney World this year
Cost
Because both a Disney World vacation and a Disney cruise can vary widely when it comes to cost, it's hard to compare the two, but we'll do our best to give you an example.
We'll compare the cost of a four-night trip in October for a family with two adults and two children (assuming a stay at the cheapest available Deluxe resort hotel, three sit-down meals and three park days at Disney World without park hopping but with Genie+ for two days) to a four-night October sailing out of Port Canaveral on the newest Disney ship sailing, Disney Wish, in a room with a verandah.
Disney World vacation cost:
- Moderate resort stay at Disney's Animal Kingdom Lodge for four nights from Oct. 7 to 11, 2024, plus three days of park tickets: $3,243.82
- Two days of Genie+ and Lightning Lanes: $350 (estimated)
- Disney Dining Plan: $992
- Total: $4,585
Disney Cruise vacation cost:
- Oct. 7 to 11, 2024, sailing on Disney Wish in a verandah room: $5,550.12 (not including gratuities or extras)
Related: 11 ways to save money on a Disney Cruise
The reality is that a Disney cruise can be cheaper or more expensive than a Disney World vacation, largely depending on when you sail — and, of course, which cabin you choose.
While prices vary seasonally at Disney World, they don't vary quite as dramatically as at sea. For this exercise, I picked an October week that is fall break for some schools for comparison, but a four-night Disney cruise on Disney Fantasy out of Port Canaveral in mid-January 2025 can be purchased starting at $3,479 for the same family of four.
Winner: A Disney World vacation costs less than a Disney cruise in this exercise. A cruise can be cheaper than a park trip, but keep in mind that demand and prices for Disney cruises are currently pretty high. The odds are decent that a cruise will cost you a little more than a similar Disney World trip right now, at least during traditional school breaks.
Accommodations
At Disney World, you can choose from Value resorts with rooms starting around $100 per night and three-bedroom grand villas (bookable with cash or rented Disney Vacation Club points) with themes ranging from the South Pacific to the African savannah — or an option that falls somewhere in between.
On a Disney cruise, most cabins measure between 169 and 237 square feet (not including any verandahs), with just a few very expensive cabins coming in larger.
Winner: Disney World is the clear winner in this category. While the Disney cruise cabins are certainly functional, it's hard to beat Disney World's variety of lodging options with multiple layouts, price points and themes.
Related: The best Disney World hotels
Activities
You'd have to try hard to be bored on a Disney cruise. The ships have so much more than pools and waterslides.
Each ship offers a sunup to after-sundown schedule of mostly included activities ranging from trivia, game shows and karaoke to Broadway-caliber performances, pirate parties, character meet-and-greets and more. Onboard kids and teen clubs are free to use and offer activities for children ages 3 to 17 years old.
When the ship pulls into port, you can do everything from dog sledding in Alaska to gelato tasting in the Mediterranean to relaxing on a beach in the Caribbean.
Related: 10 things to know about sailing on a Disney Alaska cruise
Winner: Disney Cruise Line shines when it comes to available activities. While Disney World has no shortage of activities within its theme parks, water parks and Disney Springs entertainment area, a Disney cruise offers an even wider variety of activities, especially if you count all the things to do at each port.
Related: The 5 best destinations you can visit on a Disney Cruise Line ship
Dining
Disney World offers a wide range of terrific restaurants. Options include dining "in space," eating barbecue with the toys from "Toy Story" and enjoying fine French cuisine. Vacationers can splurge on truly fine dining at Victoria & Albert's within Disney's Grand Floridian Resort & Spa and during a fantastic multicourse Japanese meal at Takumi-Tei within Epcot — it's not all chicken fingers and midmarket options.
And if you like to budget your meals in advance, the Disney Dining Plan has made its return in early 2024 after a four-year hiatus. The Dining Plan allows you to prepay for your Disney meals and snacks for prices that range from $57 to $94 per adult, per day and $23 to $26 per child, per day, depending on which plan you select. It's possible to spend less on Disney meals by going that route if you are strategic about when and where you eat.
On all Disney cruise ships, guests eat free in three dinner venues on a rotating basis, and their servers follow them from restaurant to restaurant. On Disney Wish, for example, your serving team will join you each night in the three restaurants: Worlds of Marvel, Arendelle: A Frozen Dining Adventure and 1923. A table is waiting for you each night, and your serving team gets to know you and your dining preferences. A show is included with two of the three restaurants, and the whole experience is a focal point of the day.
The food is pretty good, too. It's not necessarily on the same level as the highest-end Disney World fine dining restaurants, but if you want that, go to the adults-only restaurants that do cost a bit extra, such as Palo or Enchante, to get that same type of experience (but for a lot less).
Winner: A Disney cruise trumps Disney World for dining thanks to its convenient options and innovative rotational dining system. Not to mention, you can enjoy multiple meals and snacks each day without paying a cent beyond your original cruise fare.
Thrill factor
Y'all know where this one is heading — and yes, if you are after thrills, the thrill rides at Disney World tip this category into the theme park's corner. It's hard to beat the almost 60 mph launch on Tron Lightcycle Run or the backward launch on Guardians of the Galaxy: Cosmic Rewind.
Disney cruise ships feature some tame waterslides, though the AquaDunk waterslide on Disney Magic is not for the faint of heart. If you want a good adrenaline rush at sea, book that ship. You might also find that hanging out at the front of the ship while it's heading out to sea is pretty cool in its own right. You might be able to find some thrills in port (like a zip lining excursion in Alaska), but it depends on your cruise destination.
Winner: Disney World is the clear winner if you want thrill-seeking to be the focus of the trip. Just be sure to load up on Lightening Lanes for Rock 'n' Roller Coaster Starring Aerosmith, The Twilight Zone Tower of Terror, Expedition Everest — Legend of the Forbidden Mountain, Guardians of the Galaxy: Cosmic Rewind, Space Mountain and Tron Lightcycle Run. Save the cruise for a different type of vacation.
Multigeneration-friendly
Disney World is often a strenuous vacation for many families. That's because it's the size of San Francisco, meaning you'll generally cover 10 miles or more on foot per day just to get around, and you will often feel compelled to start early and/or stay late to feel like you're getting your money's worth.
That can be tough for anyone not used to that pace (and heat), but it can be an especially challenging vacation for those who are significantly older or younger than the rest of their group. Even if your family members can handle the distance using scooters and/or strollers, not all attractions are a great match for everyone due to height restrictions and the rough impact of certain thrill rides.
On the other hand, a Disney cruise excels at having something for every age group. Even if everyone fills their days differently — splitting up to enjoy the various kids and teen clubs and adults-only bars and restaurants — you can meet up again for the shows and meals in the evening.
Winner: Disney Cruise Line excels when it comes to multigenerational vacations. From the nursery and kids and teen clubs to the onboard talks, adults-only pool area, waterslides, drink tastings and evening programming, I can't think of a better trip for a mixed-generation group than a Disney cruise. You can find something to please just about everyone within a few decks.
Relaxation
As fun as the theme parks are — and they really are — I wouldn't call them truly relaxing trips. Sure, you could spend your days by the pool or even the spa, but most of the time, a trip to Disney World is a fun, busy adventure.
Disney cruises differ in that Disney Cruise Line ships are made for you to spend time relaxing and enjoying the ride — out on the deck, in the spa or even in your cabin gazing out the window. "Busy" on a cruise means a schedule packed with meals, pool time and the occasional participatory game show, not hauling miles and miles across a theme park to get in the next line.
Winner: Disney Cruise Line wins this category, as a Disney cruise feels far more relaxing than a Disney World vacation.
Service
Service is a strength of the Disney company both on land and at sea; however, the staffing ratios and nature of the interaction at sea tip the scales in favor of Disney Cruise Line. The crew can provide far more personalized and higher-quality service aboard Disney's ships than is possible in a theme park. At Disney World, your interactions with staff usually last just a few seconds as you climb aboard the next attraction or pay for that Dole Whip ice cream treat.
Even on the shorter cruises, some of the onboard staff will get to know your family's names and your kids' preferences. It's not uncommon for your dinner servers and room hosts to start to feel like friends, especially if you are on one of the slightly longer voyages.
Winner: A Disney cruise features all kinds of service extras you won't get on land, such as towel animals waiting for you in your cabin each evening and your favorite drinks magically appearing as soon as you sit down to dinner. This level of service is what makes a Disney cruise feel magical in ways that are too difficult to recreate at the parks.
Bottom line
My family and I are avid fans of both Disney World and Disney cruises. We make multiple trips to the theme parks in Florida annually and have taken seven Disney cruises, with several more already booked. While there are similarities between the two trips — the characters, the approaches to immersive storytelling, the service provided and the overall quality — the two vacations are different in many ways.
For us, we head to Disney World for busy fun, often meeting up with friends for an action-packed day full of rides and shows. We'll be on the go nonstop, doing and seeing all the things and often not getting a ton of sleep. We love the parks and want to return whenever we are packing up to leave, but we usually need a long nap the second we get back home.
A Disney cruise, on the other hand, truly feels like a vacation.
Depending on the sailing, the ports might be the highlight of the trip, especially in destinations such as Alaska and Europe. On others, the sea days when we snack all day, go to trivia games, order Mickey bars from room service, pop into an onboard Disney movie and simply enjoy being together as a family are the best part.
Looking at a Disney cruise versus Disney World, it's hard to say which is the better family vacation. It all depends on what you want from the trip.
If you wish to truly relax, enjoy attentive service and pull off a multigeneration trip with something for everyone, look to Disney cruises first.
If you want to fill your days with thrills, fireworks and your favorite characters, can handle logging some serious miles and aren't scared off by navigating Genie+ and making dining reservations, then book that trip to Disney World. Save the cruise for when you want to relax a bit more.
As for me, I'm hoping you'll find us at Disney World and on a Disney cruise this year because they are both the perfect family vacation for us — as long as we set the correct expectations before we embark on our adventure.
And, of course, if your budget and time-off schedule permit, you don't have to choose between the two trips. Many Disney Cruise Line sailings depart from Port Canaveral, which is only a one-hour drive (or Disney bus ride) away from Disney World, so you can easily combine several busy, thrill-seeking days at the parks with a short three- or four-night Disney cruise to create one weeklong trip.
Now that is what we call a vacation win.
Related reading:
- The best credit cards for your Disney vacation
- 13 new rides, attractions and experiences coming to Disney World in 2024
- The 21 most underrated things at Disney World: What to see, do and eat that many guests miss
- 26 Disney cruise tips, tricks, secrets and extra magic to unlock when setting sail with Mickey
- Everything we know about Disney Treasure, coming to Disney Cruise Line in 2024