View more in

Apollo 11 ascent stage that helped Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin return safely from the lunar surface may still be orbiting the moon and not crashed as previously believed, study finds

Daily Mail
Daily Mail

History changed forever after Neil Armstrong said, 'The Eagle has landed,' but a new study suggests that part of the Apollo 11 'Eagle' Lunar Module (LM), once thought to have crashed on the moon, may still orbit the celestial satellite.

California space enthusiast James Meador ran simulations of the predicted orbit of the ascent stage of the LM using the General Mission Analysis Tool (GMAT), which was developed by NASA as part of the GRAIL spacecraft, and found that it may still orbit the moon at roughly 100 kilometers, the same distance it was left at.

'These results indicate that the "Eagle" might remain in lunar orbit today,' Meador wrote in the study.
The ascent stage of the Apollo 11 'Eagle' Lunar Module may still orbit the moon, according to a new study. It may orbit the moon at roughly 100 kilometers, the same distance it was left at

Meador's simulations show that the perilune altitude of the Eagle in the time periods of 1969-1970 and 2019-2020 were roughly the same.
Meador's simulations show that the perilune altitude of the Eagle in the time periods of 1969-1970 and 2019-2020 were roughly the same
On July 21, Armstrong and Aldrin used the ascent stage to rendezvous with the Columbia command module
It's assumed the lunar module crashed into the moon's surface, but its fate is unknown

Scroll down for video

He continued: 'Although catastrophic outcomes are possible, there exists some possibility that this machine might have reached an inert state, allowing it to remain in orbit to the present day. If so, it should be detectable by radar, similarly to the way that the Indian Moon orbiter Chandrayaan-1 was relocated in 2016 (JPL, 2017).

'A rough analysis indicates that Eagle would be more than 125 [kilometers] above the surface in about 25 [percent] of limb crossings. If one assumes radar is able to detect objects at this altitude, then four judiciously chosen 2-hour observation periods should provide sufficient coverage to possibly relocate one of the most important artifacts in the history of space exploration.'

The location of Apollo 11's lunar module is the only lunar module of the Apollo missions that is not known, according to the Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum.


The ascent stage of the Eagle Lunar Module (ELM) housed Aldrin and Armstrong, as well as instrument panels and flight controls.

It had its own Ascent Propulsion System engine, as well as two hypergolic propellant tanks, so that it could return to lunar orbit and rendezvous with the Apollo command module.

In addition, it had a Reaction Control System that let the astronauts control their attitude and translation, with 16 thrusters similar to what was used on the Service Module.

It also had a forward EVA hatch that let Aldrin and Armstrong step down and up from the lunar surface.

The overhead hatch and docking port provided access to and from the Command Module. has reached out to NASA with a request for comment.

The ascent stage of the Eagle lander, an 'irregularly shaped unit approximately 2.8 [meters] high and 4.0 by 4.3 meters in width,' according to NASA, housed astronauts Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin during their descent to the moon and subsequent return.

On July 21, Armstrong and Aldrin left the surface of the moon, with their cargo of 22 kilograms of lunar rock, using the ascent stage to rendezvous with the Columbia command module and pilot Michael Collins, who died earlier this year at the age of 90.
From left to right: Apollo 11 Commander Neil A. Armstrong, Command Module Pilot Michael Collins, and Lunar Module Pilot Edwin Aldrin
Apollo 11 astronaut Buzz Aldrin (pictured) takes his last step off the Eagle lunar module onto the surface of the Moon

Once they boarded the command module, the ascent stage was discarded and long believed to have crash landed onto the surface of the moon.

According to NASA, it's assumed the lunar module crashed into the surface of the moon between one and four months after the mission ended.

However, its fate is unknown after it was jettisoned into lunar orbit on July 22, 1969, two days after Armstrong and Aldrin first stepped on the moon.

In an interview with New Scientist, Meador said that it would be incredible if the ascent stage of Apollo 11's Eagle Lunar Module still existed.

'A lot of people would be really excited to hear this thing still existed,' said Meador. 'It would be amazing to bring it back to Earth and put it in a museum.'

As exciting as a discovery like this would be, Meador cautioned, however, the ascent stage may have also been completely destroyed once Armstrong and Aldrin were safely with Collins, on their way back to Earth.

'It must be remembered that the Lunar Modules were designed for 10-day missions, and little consideration was given to long-term reliability,' Meader wrote in the study.

'For this reason, fuel leaks might have resulted in propulsive events or even complete destruction at any time after the craft was jettisoned.'

The study is available on the preprint arXiv server and can be



Apollo was the NASA programme that launched in 1961 and got the first man on the moon eight years later.

The first four flights tested the equipment for the Apollo Program and six of the other seven flights managed to land on the moon.

The first manned mission to the moon was Apollo 8 which circled around it on Christmas Eve in 1968 but did not land.

The crew of Apollo 9 spent ten days orbiting Earth and completed the first manned flight of the lunar module – the section of the Apollo rocket that would later land Neil Armstrong on the Moon.

The Apollo 11 mission was the first one to land on the moon on 20 July 1969.

The capsule landed on the Sea of Tranquillity, carrying mission commander Neil Armstrong and pilot Buzz Aldrin.

Armstrong and Aldrin walked on the lunar surface while Michael Collins remained in orbit around the moon.

When Armstrong became the first person to walk on the moon, he said, 'That's one small step for (a) man; one giant leap for mankind.'

Apollo 12 landed later that year on 19 November on the Ocean of Storms, writes NASA.

Apollo 13 was to be the third mission to land on the moon, but just under 56 hours into flight, an oxygen tank explosion forced the crew to cancel the lunar landing and move into the Aquarius lunar module to return back to Earth.

Apollo 15 was the ninth manned lunar mission in the Apollo space program, and considered at the time the most successful manned space flight up to that moment because of its long duration and greater emphasis on scientific exploration than had been possible on previous missions.

The last Apollo moon landing happened in 1972 after a total of 12 astronauts had touched down on the lunar surface.
Astronaut Edwin 'Buzz' Aldrin unpacking experiments from the Lunar Module on the moon during the Apollo 11 mission. Photographed by Neil Armstrong, 20 July 1969

Comments / 0

Comments / 0