The one question Josh Frydenberg won't answer: Leigh Sales grills Treasurer over why companies WON'T be forced to pay back their JobKeeper payments despite enjoying record profits

  • Leigh Sales grilled Josh Frydenberg following his budget announcement
  • Big companies have pocketed millions in JobKeeper despite profits booming
  • Harvey Norman founder Gerry Harvey defended receiving $14.5million subsidies
  • Sales asked Frydenberg why the Government wasn't demanding the money back

Leigh Sales has grilled Treasurer Josh Frydenberg over why companies won't be forced to repay JobKeeper payments to the federal government despite reaping the benefits of soaring profits during the pandemic.

Companies including Harvey Norman, Mercedes Benz and Ford were condemned for pocketing a combined $57million in emergency JobKeeper payments even though their sales boomed amid the economic downturn. 

ADVERTISEMENT

On ABC's 7:30 Report following Mr Frydenberg's Budget announcement on Tuesday night, Sales asked the Treasurer why the Government wasn't chasing down firms that banked JobKeeper payments as a profit when they 'never really needed it'.

'At the time, our priority was to get the money out the door,' Mr Frydenberg replied. 

On ABC's 7:30 Report following Frydenberg's budget announcement on Tuesday night, Leigh Sales asked the Treasurer why the Government wasn't chasing down firms that banked JobKeeper payments as a profit when they 'never really needed it'

The veteran reporter said she wasn't disputing the urgency of sending businesses fast cash, but again asked why the money wasn't being chased up now.

'The rules and the law that passed the parliament was that businesses could access JobKeeper based on an anticipated turnover reduction of more than 30%, or 50%, depending on the size of the company,' he said.

'It helped stabilise the economy. So we're not going to retrospectively change the legislation. We're not going to knock on the door of every small business.'

Sales hit back, saying the Coalition would be outraged if the Labor Party were 'just writing it off' and not holding companies accountable.

Mr Frydenberg continued to spruik the success of the JobKeeper program while avoiding answering Sales' line of questioning.  

'Just because it did do the job it was intended doesn't mean that it's flawless or that there wasn't waste built into it,' Sales said.

'As I point out, if you're spending at these levels, surely trying to minimise waste and inefficiency has to be an utter priority?'

Mr Frydenberg continued to spruik the success of the JobKeeper program while avoiding answering Sales' line of questioning

Mr Frydenberg retorted that the program worked 'very effectively' through the tax system before taking aim at the Labor Party. 

'Labor asked us to extend JobKeeper beyond a year. We said no. It was costing, at that time, more than $2billion a month. And we have seen, in the month of April, more than 100,000 people come off income support, even as JobKeeper ended.

ADVERTISEMENT

'Labor said they would spend more. They said the sky would fall in if JobKeeper ended. It hasn't. And that step that we took - that decision we took - has proven to be the right one.'   

Harvey Norman's billionaire founder Gerry Harvey previously defended receiving $14.5million in wage subsidies despite posting a 116 per cent profit increase

Harvey Norman's billionaire founder Gerry Harvey previously defended receiving $14.5million in wage subsidies despite posting a 116 per cent profit increase. 

The electrical retailer made a record $462million after tax profit in the six months to December 31 as lockdowns made consumers more inclined to update their home furnishings.

That $248.4million increase - compared with the second half of 2019 before the pandemic - marked a 116.3 per cent half-year net profit surge.

Mercedes-Benz pocketed almost $5 million in JobKeeper payments despite recording a $62.7 million profit in Australia last year - up from a $25 million loss in 2019.

Ford was handed $38 million in JobKeeper last year, while also enjoying a $59 million profit. 

Footwear retailer Accent Group also faced pressure to return more than $9million in JobKeeper payments after hitting a record $52.8million in profit in their December half.

Mercedes-Benz pocketed almost $5 million in JobKeeper payments despite recording a $62.7 million profit in Australia last year - up from a $25 million loss in 2019

WINNERS AND LOSERS IN THE 2021/22 BUDGET 

WINNERS

Small Business - Incentives to innovate and grow

Taxpayers - Extended relief for low and middle income earners

Elderly - More home care packages and a radical overhaul of aged care system

Women - Steps towards better safety and respect in the workplace

People with mental health issues - Big focus on new types of services

LOSERS

Underemployed - Virtually no mention of underemployment as an issue

Recreation and culture sector - Drop in funding of 19 per cent in real terms over next four years

Sport sector - Drop in expenses of 42 per cent in real terms over four years

National parks - Drop in expenses of 19 per cent over four years

Rural assistance - To fall by 39 per cent in real terms over four years

Air transport - 75.6 per cent dip in expenses over four years 

ADVERTISEMENT

Most Read News

Two 'seriously' injured runaway Household Cavalry horses undergo operations and are being 'closely...

Harvey Weinstein's rape conviction overturned over 'crucial mistake' by New York judge... and he...

Physically healthy Dutch woman hopes to become the latest person in the country to end her life by...

Cambridge student, 28, tortured to death after he was mistaken for a spy had legs, arms, seven ribs...

Russia threatens to strike POLAND: Kremlin says NATO nukes deployed in the country will be a...

Unbelievable moment policing minister Chris Philp leaves Question Time audience gasping as he asks...

Captain Tom's scandal-hit daughter Hannah Ingram-Moore is selling family's £2.25m Bedfordshire...

Astonishing moment 'out of control' wealthy businessman drags parish councillor by the hair after...

Billionaire heiress, 16, whose mom founded Flickr and dad founded Slack vanishes in San Francisco's...

LIZ JONES: How the past few days have shown us the depth of Kate and Charles's special relationship...

Abusive husband beat his wife to death with son's skateboard while police waited outside for...

Revealed: Teenage boy arrested for 'making threats with a BB gun' is the brother of Year 9 girl...

Kung Fu Pandas! Shocking moment zookeeper is mauled in front of screaming onlookers in China - until...

Humza Yousaf on the brink of being OUSTED as Scotland's First Minister as SNP's former coalition...

Horror after two people are stabbed on major north London high street: Woman in her 20s is rushed to...

I worked at the same shoe shop for 68 years - then I was given the boot with just a few days'...