A Long List! See Timeline of Angelina Pivarnick’s Drama With the ‘Jersey Shore’ Cast

Season 1, 2009

Angelina only lasted three episodes on season 1 of Jersey Shore and was sent home by Danny after she refused to work at the Shore Store. Although she wasn’t there for very long, she definitely left her mark.

When she said goodbye to her roommates, they didn’t seem sad to see her leave.

Season 2, 2010

Although Ang left during season 1, she gave things another shot and showed up for season 2 in Miami. She caused a lot of drama in the house, first by slapping Pauly in the face and later by sleeping with her boyfriend in Mike’s bed. She called several people in the house “fake” and got into two physical altercations with Snooki. She eventually left the house and was replaced by Deena in the following seasons of the series.

Throwing Shade, 2016

Although Angelina moved on to become an EMT in Staten Island following her departure from the show, she still took the time to throw shade at Snooki and her new plump lips. “She’s trying to copy my look,” she exclusively told In Touch at the time. “It’s funny how she goes and gets her lips done at the same exact place that I got mine done. Yeah, so now all the times on [Jersey Shore] she used to call me ugly, now she’s trying to look like me.”

Taking Their Feud to Twitter

After Angelina spoke about her old costar, Snooki took to Twitter to slam her former pal for her harsh words. “Damn I thought she changed. I gave her a compliment about her lips, and she referred me to her [doctor]. We’re grown adults. C’mon girl.” In response, Angelina replied, “When I tried to contact you to say thank you for that you ignored me. We need to grow up and put things past us. I tried.”

“Sorry I didn’t get back to you,” Nicole replied. “But you ‘tried’ by talking crap about me. All love here, just baffled.”

Returns to Jersey Shore: Family Vacation, May 2018

Pauly thought it would be fun to prank his pals with a blast from the past. He organized for Angelina to meet the crew in Miami, and had Mike answer the door when she arrived. “Do you still think I’m a dirty little hamster?” she said when Mike opened the door. Looking shocked, he replied, “No, not at all, I didn’t even know you were alive,” he responded.

After surprising the boys, Angelina went on to right her wrongs and apologized to Mike for previously saying his manhood was a little small.

Once the girls were surprised with Angelina’s arrival, they were definitely displeased. She did what she could to put her best foot forward and win back her old roommates. Her visit in Miami was brief and she went home after a few days.

Season 2, September 2018

After calling a truce, Snooki invited Angelina to join them on their trip to Las Vegas. The other roommates were not happy when they found out she would be joining them.

Jenni especially was displeased with Angelina’s arrival and tried to confront the Staten Island native. Throughout the rest of the season, Angelina and Jenni remained frenemies.

Season 3, 2019

Angelina was back on the show as a full time castmate, and overall, she was on good terms with all of her old friends. That was until Jenni’s boyfriend Zack Clayton Carpinello was caught flirting with Angelina on camera. She insisted he came on to her. After fighting back and forth on social media and in real life, the two were able to put the incident in the past.

Angelina’s Wedding, November 2019

Angelina and the girls were on their best terms ever and were even bridesmaids at her wedding to Chris Larangeira. The girls made a speech during her reception that did not go over well. They made several insensitive jokes about the bride, calling her “the dump to their island.” Angelina stormed out of her wedding and didn’t find humor in their speech.

Wedding Drama Airs on MTV, June 2020

Following Angelina’s wedding episode, she revealed where she stood with the rest of the cast. “I texted all of them, and I spoke to them. Deena and [I] had a nice convo. Nicole I’ve texted and we spoke. Jenni I texted, ‘I wanna move past this,’ and she wrote me a novel about how I tried to sabotage her brand, etc. Not saying sorry at all,” she wrote to a fan on Twitter.

Face Off With Vinny, July 2020

Angelina’s beef with the cast only got worse since the finale aired. On Twitter, Vinny told her to “shut up,” to which she replied, “[You] are a peasant, and I am your ruler. Get that straight, and we shall be good. Whoever messes [with] the queen shall face consequences.”

On Deena’s Bad Side, July 2020

Deena also took her feud with Angelina to Twitter, writing, “For months, myself, Jenni and Nicole were getting threats and her knowing how bad it was for us she continued to play the victim and make us look  [like] terrible people … and after seeing the episode and seeing her true colors … I can care less if I ever see her again in my life.”
 
 “I’ve been getting death threats since 2009 and I still get them to this day,” Angelina clapped back in response. “I can’t control what people write to you or what they write to me. You are always going to have trolls commenting and saying stupid s–t. Don’t blame [me] for other people’s actions.”
 
It looks like Angelina’s drama with her Jersey Shore castmates is far from over.

Pauly Weighs In on the Drama

In January 2021, Pauly weighed in on Angelina’s feud with Deena, Jenni and Snooki during an exclusive interview with In Touch.

During an episode of Jersey Shore: Family Vacation, Pauly and the rest of the castmates arranged to have Angelina confront Deena and Jenni over the feud. “It was a lot of work for the guys to put that together, and that’s in real life, television and everything,” Pauly tells In Touch. “We couldn’t believe it actually happened.”

After the DJ noted the trio had a lot of “built-up animosity” following Angelina’s November 2019 nuptials, he said he “respects” both of their sides for “certain reasons.” However, Pauly said he wished the ladies didn’t let it get to that “extent.” He added at the time, “They both had valid points … but at the end of the day, we are family and families do fight.”

Angelina, Deena, Jenni and Snooki all eventually put their differences aside and made amends, which was documented on the MTV show.

Angelina Allegedly Leaks the Wedding Toast

Despite making amends on-screen, Angelina allegedly “leaked” Snooki, Jenni and Deena’s wedding toast online in February 2021. One year later, a source told The Sun that Angelina admitted to leaking the tape in February 2022.

Deena slammed Angelina in a now-deleted tweet, writing, “To think she swore on her animals’ lives she didn’t leak it. I feel like this friendship we have has been based on a lie … I’ve been there for her … and now I know she deliberately did something to hurt me … makes me sad. Unfortunately, I know the source n [sic] know it is in fact true.”

At the time, a source told The Sun that Angelina intentionally released the audio of her bridesmaids’ controversial speeches in an effort to “make them look bad.” However, Angelina denied claims she leaked the tape and tweeted that the claims were “lies.”

Vinny Responds to Fans Shipping Him With Angelina

While most of Angelina’s drama was with her female costars, she still butted heads with the men of Jersey Shore. After fans started shipping her with Vinny amid their seemingly flirty relationship and her split from estranged husband Chris, Vinny addressed whether he would consider dating his fellow Staten Island native.

“I’m on the 18th floor of my hotel. I would rather jump off this balcony than ever entertain one of those rumors,” Vinny told Us Weekly in March 2022.

“I don’t know if people think that I’m, like, capping or I’m lying about this. Like, when I tell you there’s not an ounce of energy or anything in my body that has any kind of romantic attraction toward Angelina, I promise you,” he continued, responding to fan speculation about their relationship. “I do not.”

Side Piece Allegations

Mike accused Angelina of having “side pieces” amid her marriage in the trailer for the second part of season 5 of Jersey Shore: Family Vacation, which was released in June 2022.

The first half of season 5 featured Angelina denying claims she cheated on Chris. Following a temporary split, the pair decided to work through their problems. However, they officially called it quits in January 2022 when Chris filed for divorce.

As she attempted to navigate the split, the situation became more difficult when Mike began to speculate about the reason behind the breakup. “He’s, like, in the pot and he’s [stirring],” she said in one scene.

Mike’s Plan to Hold Angelina Accountable

After the drama-filled trailer was released, Mike exclusively spoke to In Touch about why he chose to call out Angelina about the cheating rumors.

“This season is definitely a lot messier than I would like,” he said. “But at the same time, if anyone in the group’s decisions start to bleed into our life and make our life messy, that’s when I’m gonna call you out.”

Angelina Denies Cheating Claims

Angelina responded to claims that she had an affair while still married to Chris during an exclusive video interview with In Touch in June.

“I didn’t have a side piece the whole entire time I was married. That’s another lie,” she said. “I’m going to be open and honest on my Instagram page when I am allowed to about what’s not real. And what’s made up and a fake story.” She adds, “The timelines don’t add up.”

The reality star also shut down claims that she had an affair with her All Star Shore costar Luis “Potro” Caballero. “I was very open and honest. I told everybody from the jump what happened, “ she said. “Maybe that bit me in the ass a little bit, because here I am being honest and open.”

Angelina added, “I’m literally gonna set the record straight when this whole thing airs.”