undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Warren

Warren judge convicted of drunk driving after hitting SMART bus

By Kara Berg,

5 days ago

NOVI — A Warren district court judge was found guilty during a bench trial on Nov. 16 of drunk driving earlier this year, but acquitted of a more serious charge, despite having a blood alcohol content level of more than twice the state's legal limit at 0.19.

Warren District Court Judge John Chmura, who has been a district court judge for 30 years, was convicted of driving drunk and crashing into a SMART bus in Sterling Heights just before midnight on March 25.

52-1 Novi District Court Judge David Law found Chmura, 63, not guilty of operating a motor vehicle with a blood alcohol content of 0.17 or more, a misdemeanor punishable by up to a year in jail. He found Chmura guilty of operating while intoxicated, which carries a penalty of up to 93 days in jail.

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=1we2Dn_1H961ch800

The trial was held in Law's courtroom because Sterling Heights' judges recused themselves from hearing Chmura's case.

"There's no question the defendant had been drinking alcohol prior to operating this motor vehicle," Law said. "In this court's eyes, he wasn’t dead drunk. He definitely had been drinking and definitely was under the influence."

But Law's ultimate decision came down to what he called a "battle of the experts."

Michigan State Police forensic scientist Stephanie Grabowski testified that Chmura's blood alcohol content, measured from a blood draw a little over an hour after the crash, was 0.196, more than double Michigan's legal limit of .08. This test had a margin of error of 0.018, she said.

Dr. Ronald Henson, a toxicology expert Chmura called as an expert witness, said someone’s blood alcohol content could continue to increase even after they stop drinking, meaning Chmura's blood alcohol content could have been below a 0.17 — the level for the "super drunk" charge in Michigan — at the time of the crash and rose after.

Law said there was enough doubt that he could not convict Chmura of operating a motor vehicle with a blood alcohol content of 0.17 or more, which Chmura originally had been charged with. He instead convicted him of the lesser, included operating while intoxicated charge.

Chmura declined to comment after the verdict. A sentencing date will be set later.

David Kramer, Chmura's attorney, said during closing arguments that he did not deny that Chmura had too much to drink. He took the case to trial because St. Clair County prosecutors, who handled the case because the Macomb County Prosecutor's Office recused itself, refused to offer a plea deal to Chmura.

Kramer said St. Clair County "supposedly" does not offer pleas in drunk driving cases, though he added, "I hate the idea of the fact that maybe they were picking on him and holding him to a higher standard because he's a judge, because we're all human, right?"

St. Clair County Assistant Prosecutor Paul Soderberg declined to comment after the verdict, but said during closing arguments that "this case is about incredibly dangerous driving as a result of operating with a high blood alcohol content."

Two people on the bus were treated on-scene for injuries, but no one was seriously injured. The bus was stopped when it was hit.

Sterling Heights Police Officer Johnathan Journeau, who questioned Chmura shortly after the crash, testified during the trial that he knew immediately alcohol was a factor.

"There was slurred speech and immediately a whiff, an odor of intoxicants," Journeau said. "It was a strong odor. It was something I almost immediately smelled."

Journeau was one of the first people to testify Nov. 16. His body camera footage, which played in the courtroom during the trial, showed Chmura telling Journeau within seconds that he was a judge in Warren's 37th District Court.

Wearing a suit and tie in the footage, Chmura told Journeau that he had been drinking at a fundraiser for a Macomb County Circuit Court judge hopeful and had drunk “evidently too much," according to Journeau's body-worn camera.

Chmura told Journeau he did not want to do the roadside sobriety tests, and refused to allow Journeau to give him a preliminary breath test to see how intoxicated he was.

“I don’t want to do the tests, OK?” Chmura said. “Look, I’ve been on the bench for 30 years, I understand all of it, OK? You’re going to make me do the tests?”

Chmura ultimately agreed to do the sobriety tests and struggled to understand the instructions Journeau gave him. He made several mistakes while counting backwards, twice counting up instead of down. When asked to recite the alphabet from C to N, Chmura started over several times and could not tell Journeau what letter came after I.

"It's not OK. It's bad, it's bad," he said after struggling to recite the alphabet, and Journeau told him it was OK.

Journeau said he noticed Chmura was swaying side to side and front to back and had to brace himself on both his own car and against Journeau.

Journeau arrested Chmura after the sobriety tests as "he had consumed too much alcohol to be operating a motor vehicle."

Kramer, asked Journeau if people fail the sobriety tests even when they’re below the legal limit and Journeau said the test isn’t a pass-or-fail test, but people can do poorly at that level.

"His results on those sobriety tests were not necessarily indicative of what his blood alcohol content was when he hit the bus?" Kramer asked.

"That is correct," Journeau said.

Chmura ultimately agreed to take a preliminary breath test, but Journeau said that time had passed, according to the video. Chmura agreed to do a blood test to confirm his blood alcohol level.

A few minutes later, one of the officers said he was going to let Chmura take the preliminary breath test despite his earlier refusal. The officer said Chmura blew a 0.16, which is double the legal limit of 0.08. His blood alcohol content, tested later at the hospital, was 0.19, according to the police report.

Henson, the toxicology expert, said the sobriety tests of counting backwards and reciting the alphabet starting from a random letter are not validated by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration because “you’d be amazed” at people’s inability to successfully complete those tests, even while sober.

Kramer asked if someone blew a 0.16 on a breathalyzer — as Chmura did — and a blood test later showed a 0.19 blood alcohol content, if it’s possible to “skyrocket” that much in just over an hour between the tests.

“I wouldn’t call it skyrocket because it’s very reasonable someone would increase that number an hour beyond, depending on when the last drink was and what the last drink was,” Henson said, noting police should have asked Chmura when his last drink was, which they didn't do.

Police did ask Chmura what his last drink was, but he did not answer, Journeau said.

Chmura was appointed as a judge to Warren's 37th District Court in 1996. He was made chief judge in 2008.

kberg@detroitnews.com

This article originally appeared on The Detroit News: Warren judge convicted of drunk driving after hitting SMART bus

emoji_like
emoji_wow
emoji_haha
26

Comments / 7