undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
California

Experts Float Buy, Rent Back, Retreat Plan for California Coast

By Lucas Hayes,

3 hours ago

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=1rZ8Ye_1HL19fqr00

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=1rZ8Ye_1HL19fqr00

Glowing red neon sign reading “BUY” in front of an American flag, symbolizing a buyout and property sale – Image for illustrative purposes only (Image credits: nvmwebsites-budwg5g9avh3epea.z03.azurefd.net)

Record-setting high tides and a strengthening El Niño are testing California’s shoreline, and some beachfront homes are already taking on water. The Los Angeles Times reports that experts are now pushing a new response to rising seas: buy the threatened homes, rent them back to residents, and then retreat from the coast over time ([1]).

Most coastal homes have little flood protection

The financial exposure is what gives the proposal its urgency. Only 1.4 percent of California homes carry flood insurance, even though roughly 2.3 million properties face flood risk over the next 30 years, according to reporting by Inman. Standard homeowner policies typically exclude flood and storm surge damage, which leaves many owners to cover repairs on their own ([2]).

Federal coverage has limits as well. The National Flood Insurance Program caps payouts at $250,000 per residence, a ceiling that leaves many insured homes underinsured. Of the 183,000 California homes in FEMA high-risk flood zones, 65 percent have no federal flood policy, based on an analysis shared with KQED ([2]).

Tides are arriving before the worst of El Niño

Exceptionally high king tides are forecast to begin Sunday and continue through Black Friday. Coastal communities will face two more periods of extreme tides around Christmas and Martin Luther King Jr. Day ([3]). A National Weather Service meteorologist said it remains unclear how much rain will fall during the tidal peaks, so the combined effect is still uncertain.

The bigger test may come later. NBC News reported that the peak of what is predicted to be a historic El Niño is expected early next year, and that the tides this year will likely bring more flooding and erosion ([4]). A NASA analysis also found that a strong El Niño could produce up to five 10-year flood events this winter in cities including Seattle and San Diego ([5]).

How buy, rent back, then retreat would work

Coastal communities generally have three options when water reaches their homes:

  • Defend properties with seawalls and buffering beaches.
  • Learn to live with higher water.
  • Retreat to higher ground.

The buy, rent back, then retreat concept belongs to the third category, though it aims to soften the financial loss rather than abandon homes outright. The idea is not entirely new. In 2021, State Sen. Ben Allen proposed a revolving loan program that would allow counties and communities to purchase vulnerable coastal properties, then rent them out for as long as they remain habitable ([6]). The state’s nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office estimated that $8 billion to $10 billion of existing property could be underwater within 30 years ([6]).

Researchers have also tested the rent-back piece. A University of Georgia study used survey data to measure how coastal residents on the East Coast would weigh a buyout against paying to rent back their property afterward, which would remove the risk of losing the home ([7]).

Questions about cost, fairness and timing

Supporters argue that property prices do not reflect the threat. Julia Stein of UCLA’s Emmett Institute has pointed out that research suggests the market value of coastal property largely ignores sea level rise ([6]). Marine scientist Gary Griggs has backed a state-run voluntary program that would pay homeowners market rate or more to give up endangered houses ([8]).

Critics raise different objections. Environmentalists have argued that a buyout could encourage people to keep buying threatened coastal property, expecting the government to pay if they need to leave ([8]). Others have worried the scheme could end up bailing out wealthy homeowners ([9]). Policy experts also note that a program of this scale has never been attempted, and that retreat remains unpopular in many coastal towns ([10]).

Retreat advocates say the choice is shrinking. David Revell of Revell Coastal, who has analyzed coastal hazards for 25 California counties and cities, has argued that retreat is the only long-term option because “we can’t hold back the ocean” ([10]). For now, the buy, rent back, then retreat approach remains a proposal for public debate rather than a settled path for homeowners.

AI Disclaimer: This article was created with the assistance of AI tools and reviewed by a human editor.

Comments