1. 4
    🍕

    Willy's Bloomingdale Pizza Brandon

    Brandon, Florida

    4.9779 reviews$$
  2. 5
    🍕

    GulfSide Pizza & Subs

    Largo, Florida

    4.9720 reviews$$
  3. 6
    🍕

    Killer Pizza

    St. Petersburg, Florida

    4.9591 reviews$
  4. 7
    🍕

    Gershys Cafe & Catering

    Clearwater, Florida

    4.9511 reviews$$
  5. 8
    🍕

    Noventa Millas

    Tampa, Florida

    4.82,297 reviews$
  6. 9
    🍕

    Wood Fire Pizza

    Spring Hill, Florida

    4.9189 reviews
  7. 10
    🍕

    Pizza Box

    St. Petersburg, Florida

    4.81,127 reviews$$
  8. 11
    🍕

    Monte Wood Fired Pizza

    St. Petersburg, Florida

    4.9170 reviews
  9. 12
    🍕

    Hot Rocks Pizza (Town n Country)

    Tampa, Florida

    4.8939 reviews$$
  10. 13
    🍕

    Flippers Pizza Co. - South Tampa

    Tampa, Florida

    4.8766 reviews$$
  11. 14
    🍕

    Bella Roma NY Pizza

    Tampa, Florida

    4.8716 reviews$$
  12. 15
    🍕

    Pizza Joe's - a Taste of Buffalo

    Palm Harbor, Florida

    4.8696 reviews$
  13. 16
    🍕

    Right Around the Corner Arcade Bar

    St. Petersburg, Florida

    4.8680 reviews$
  14. 17
    🍕

    Bruno’s Pizzeria

    St. Petersburg, Florida

    4.9148 reviews
  15. 18
    🍕

    Tuscan Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

    Largo, Florida

    4.9144 reviews
  16. 19
    🍕

    Mi Pizza Piu LLC

    Ruskin, Florida

    4.8521 reviews
  17. 20
    🍕

    Prima New York Pizza

    New Port Richey, Florida

    4.8439 reviews
  18. 21
    🍕

    Essential Pizza

    Land O' Lakes, Florida

    4.9129 reviews$$
  19. 22
    🍕

    Piper's Scratch Pizza Shop

    Palm Harbor, Florida

    4.8385 reviews$
  20. 23
    🍕

    Vinny D's Pizza take out

    New Port Richey, Florida

    4.8341 reviews
  21. 24
    🍕

    Verola's Pizzeria

    Clearwater, Florida

    4.8318 reviews
  22. 25
    🍕

    Pitza Pizza - Home of the Pizza Ring

    Tampa, Florida

    4.8311 reviews$
  23. 26
    🍕

    Cheese Wheel Pasta & Pizza

    Clearwater, Florida

    4.8237 reviews
  24. 27
    🍕

    Bella Roma Pizza

    Lutz, Florida

    4.8209 reviews$$
  25. 28
    🍕

    Papa Johns Pizza

    Valrico, Florida

    4.8182 reviews
  26. 29
    🍕

    Merlins Pizza

    Destin, Florida

    4.77,173 reviews$
  27. 30
    🍕

    Pickle & Pint

    Largo, Florida

    4.8163 reviews
  28. 31
    🍕

    Cristino's Coal Oven Pizza

    Clearwater, Florida

    4.74,380 reviews$$
  29. 32
    🍕

    Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar

    Tampa, Florida

    4.73,756 reviews$
  30. 33
    🍕

    Gulfside Pizza & Subs

    Clearwater, Florida

    4.981 reviews
  31. 34
    🍕

    The NONA Slice House

    Safety Harbor, Florida

    4.72,623 reviews$$
  32. 35
    🍕

    Fazoli's

    Clermont, Florida

    4.72,478 reviews$
  33. 36
    🍕

    Super Sardo's Pizza

    Largo, Florida

    4.72,263 reviews$
  34. 37
    🍕

    Flippers Pizza Co. - St. Petersburg

    St. Petersburg, Florida

    4.72,215 reviews$$
  35. 38
    🍕

    Slice of The Burg

    St. Petersburg, Florida

    4.72,156 reviews$
  36. 39
    🍕

    Local Pizza Company

    St. Petersburg, Florida

    4.71,947 reviews$$
  37. 40
    🍕

    Your Pizza Shop

    Largo, Florida

    4.71,549 reviews$
  38. 41
    🍕

    Mama B's Pizzeria

    Wesley Chapel, Florida

    4.71,543 reviews$
  39. 42
    🍕

    Jay Luigi

    St. Petersburg, Florida

    4.7958 reviews$$
  40. 43
    🍕

    Baba Dough Pizza bar

    Tampa, Florida

    4.8135 reviews
  41. 44
    🍕

    Salerno Pizza

    Stuart, Florida

    4.7860 reviews$
  42. 45
    🍕

    Florida Cracker Tap Room and Bourbon Bar

    Brooksville, Florida

    4.7854 reviews$$
  43. 46
    🍕

    Gigi's Pizza and Pasta

    Spring Hill, Florida

    4.7777 reviews$
  44. 47
    🍕

    Slice of the Hillz

    Zephyrhills, Florida

    4.7710 reviews
  45. 48
    🍕

    New World Tampa

    Tampa, Florida

    4.7573 reviews$$
  46. 49
    🍕

    Gone Juicing x Pizza

    New Port Richey, Florida

    4.8118 reviews$
  47. 50
    🍕

    Pizzaissimo

    Brandon, Florida

    4.7450 reviews$$

Ranked by a Bayesian-adjusted rating that balances star average with review volume, so a shop with 8 five-star reviews doesn't outrank a beloved neighborhood spot with hundreds.