1. 4
    🍕

    Mateo Pizza Restaurant

    San Mateo, California

    4.9472 reviews$$
  2. 5
    🍕

    Arthur Mac's Little Snack

    Emeryville, California

    4.9329 reviews$$
  3. 6
    🍕

    Roll N Crust

    Fremont, California

    4.9324 reviews
  4. 7
    🍕

    Mazza Pizza n Grill

    San Jose, California

    5.0129 reviews
  5. 8
    🍕

    Pizzeria Luba

    Auburn, California

    4.9277 reviews
  6. 9
    🍕

    Cheese Board Collective Pizzeria

    Berkeley, California

    4.83,914 reviews$
  7. 10
    🍕

    Arizmendi Bakery (Lakeshore)

    Oakland, California

    4.81,847 reviews$
  8. 11
    🍕

    Mountain Mike's Pizza

    Dixon, California

    4.9188 reviews
  9. 12
    🍕

    Pizzarito NY Pizza By The Slice

    Marina Del Rey, California

    4.8993 reviews$$
  10. 13
    🍕

    Gusto Pinsa Romana

    San Francisco, California

    4.8982 reviews$$
  11. 14
    🍕

    Fire Slice Pizza

    Concord, California

    4.9169 reviews
  12. 15
    🍕

    Pizza joven

    Oakland, California

    4.9167 reviews$$
  13. 16
    🍕

    Ellie's Pizzeria

    Walnut Creek, California

    4.9166 reviews
  14. 17
    🍕

    Sonoma Pizza Co.

    Forestville, California

    4.8820 reviews$$
  15. 18
    🍕

    Sofra Urbana

    Fountain Valley, California

    4.8654 reviews$$
  16. 19
    🍕

    Apizza Doho

    Dana Point, California

    4.8557 reviews$$
  17. 20
    🍕

    State Flour Pizza Company

    Berkeley, California

    4.9147 reviews$$
  18. 21
    🍕

    South Bay Pizza

    Redondo Beach, California

    4.8542 reviews$$
  19. 22
    🍕

    CROCCANTE ARTISAN PIZZA

    Napa, California

    4.8487 reviews$
  20. 23
    🍕

    Pizzaleah

    Windsor, California

    4.8440 reviews$$
  21. 24
    🍕

    Grand Comedy Club & Pizzeria

    Escondido, California

    4.8435 reviews
  22. 25
    🍕

    Mazala Pizza San Jose

    San Jose, California

    4.8408 reviews
  23. 26
    🍕

    Pizza Guys

    Corona, California

    4.8370 reviews$
  24. 27
    🍕

    Tandoori Pizza - Pleasanton

    Pleasanton, California

    4.9126 reviews
  25. 28
    🍕

    Tandoori Pizza - Milpitas

    Milpitas, California

    4.8342 reviews
  26. 29
    🍕

    Curry Pizza House San Mateo

    San Mateo, California

    4.8276 reviews$$
  27. 30
    🍕

    Curry Pizza House Berkeley

    Berkeley, California

    4.8271 reviews$$
  28. 31
    🍕

    Tasty Bites Pizzeria

    Vallejo, California

    4.9107 reviews$$
  29. 32
    🍕

    The Thyme Pizzeria

    Winnetka, California

    4.8254 reviews$
  30. 33
    🍕

    Pizza Twist

    Berkeley, California

    4.8234 reviews$
  31. 34
    🍕

    Cake Garden Bakery

    Lawndale, California

    4.9101 reviews$$
  32. 35
    🍕

    Massilia - DTLA

    Los Angeles, California

    4.8226 reviews
  33. 36
    🍕

    Cafe Napolina

    Concord, California

    4.8218 reviews$$
  34. 37
    🍕

    Pizza Wings El Buen Sabor

    San Jose, California

    4.8211 reviews$
  35. 38
    🍕

    Psychic Pie

    Sebastopol, California

    4.8208 reviews$$
  36. 39
    🍕

    Tony Tutto Pizza

    Ross, California

    4.8203 reviews$$
  37. 40
    🍕

    Corner Slice

    Livermore, California

    4.8185 reviews
  38. 41
    🍕

    Lebbers

    Atascadero, California

    4.985 reviews
  39. 42
    🍕

    Tastivo Pizza

    Winnetka, California

    4.8169 reviews
  40. 43
    🍕

    Golden Boy Pizza

    San Francisco, California

    4.74,913 reviews$
  41. 44
    🍕

    Zachary's Chicago Pizza

    Oakland, California

    4.72,911 reviews$$
  42. 45
    🍕

    High & Mighty Pizza Joint

    Gilroy, California

    4.8153 reviews$
  43. 46
    🍕

    A Slice of New York

    San Jose, California

    4.72,032 reviews$
  44. 47
    🍕

    Arizmendi Bakery

    San Francisco, California

    4.71,977 reviews$
  45. 48
    🍕

    7 Hills Pizzeria

    Ladera Ranch, California

    4.978 reviews
  46. 49
    🍕

    Olive Oil Pantry Restaurant

    Lathrop, California

    4.8145 reviews
  47. 50
    🍕

    Diavola Pizzeria & Salumeria

    Geyserville, California

    4.71,327 reviews$$

Ranked by a Bayesian-adjusted rating that balances star average with review volume, so a shop with 8 five-star reviews doesn't outrank a beloved neighborhood spot with hundreds.