undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Caldwell approves massive subdivision and commercial project
By MARIELA ESQUIVEL-RODRIGUEZ,
2026-05-07CALDWELL — A high-end real estate development company gets to check off Caldwell from its Treasure Valley building bingo card.
Following a long night at City Hall on Monday, council members made a statement with their votes about what kind of development is appropriate for a continuously fast-growing city.
Although the council has been divided on developers building more homes in a city that is trying to keep up with rapid growth, they saw eye to eye Monday night by voting unanimously to annex 284 acres of land south of Karcher Road that would bring in nearly 1,000 new homes and 13 commercial lots to Caldwell over the next five to 10 years.
The 284-acre vacant land annexed consists of five separate parcels located on the north and south sides of Karcher Road between South 10th Avenue and South Indiana Avenue. The project considered is to be an infill project because of the development already in place surrounding the area, which includes two schools from the Vallivue School District, Gem State Academy and other single-family homes.
M3 Companies, which has developed projects in every other jurisdiction in the Treasure Valley, now gets to check Caldwell off its bingo card after local manager, Mark Tate, successfully impressed the council with a high-end mixed-use subdivision proposal.
Three of the five parcels were requested for a preliminary plat to be zoned residential to build 991 residential units; 655 of the units will be single-family homes, and 336 units will be multi-family homes that will sit at the corner of South Montana Avenue and Karcher Road but will be built at a later date.
The Silverleaf subdivision will be similar to the Summit Ridge subdivision M3 built in Nampa, where homes have an average price of more than two times the median home price in Caldwell, according to Tate, who said the same concept would apply for the proposed subdivision, meaning the city would generate twice of its property tax revenue.
“We do very-high-end communities, high property values, and it’s really a product that Caldwell doesn’t have a lot of that’s very different from what’s out there today,” Tate said.
Amenities within the subdivision include a pool, pickleball court, clubhouse, playground and 14.5% left for open space. He referred to the project as “the poster child for responsible growth”
More than 47 acres of land for commercial development was approved near South 10th Avenue, South Indiana Avenue and Karcher Road intersections. This includes a site plan that would have an Albertsons grocery store within a mixed-use shopping center on South Indiana Avenue, according to Tate, who said it is “not a small amount of commercial right there. It’s something that will be very meaningful.”
The large area designated for accessible commercial use was something Council Member Diana Register appreciated about the developer, who she felt was “trying to do something in the middle,” but she still wanted to ensure that Caldwell residents had more community gathering and dining options to go to.
She was one of three council members Monday night who denied a developer’s request to build a mixed-use subdivision near South 10th Avenue and Ustick Road because it was intended to only be for commercial use.
“It’s nice to have a developer come here and say that you’re thinking about us and that you’re not trying to cram in more and more, or that you’re taking into consideration what Caldwell is becoming, and it’s not just a dumping ground anymore,” Register said.
Representatives from the Gem State Academy, a private Seventh-Day Adventist High School located in the middle of one of the requested parcels, spoke in favor of the project. The Seventh-day Adventist Church wanted to use the land surrounding Gem State Academy as an endowment that could benefit the school long-term. It chose to work with Tate and M3 companies two years ago.
“We feel that their track record of beautiful communities across the Treasure Valley will again produce a community that we and the city of Caldwell can be proud of,” John Rodgers said.
Caldwell residents raised concerns during public comment regarding the Vallivue School District’s school capacity, insufficient water and traffic issues. A nearby neighbor, Sue Hulse, also raised concerns about the project being near the National Wildlife Refuge, home to many migratory birds.
“I think it’s just important for the city of Caldwell to show what you are for,” Tate said. “There really is not a better suited property for development to be able to say yes.”
After more than an hour of long deliberation from the council, the dais passed all annexations with various staff requests, recommendations and conditions for approval, some including working with Gem State Academy to build a pathway and sidewalks and no more than 40% of commercial buildings to be used for offices spaces and medical type uses.