undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Defendants in poisoning case want to get trial split
By NEIL JOHNSON,
2 days agoJANESVILLE — Lawyers for the couple accused in an elaborate plot to poison a town of Fulton woman continue to seek having an attempted homicide trial against them that's slated for March 2027 split into two separate trials.
Attorneys for defendants Paul VanDuyne and Andrea Whitaker, both of Madison, continue to seek that VanDuyne and Whitaker be severed, with their attorneys arguing that testimony one could give at trial might incriminate the other.
That's based on attorneys' speculation over text messages that the Rock County District Attorney's Office says it has between VanDuyne and Whitaker talking about active steps to sneak onto Amanda Bade's rural town of Fulton property four times in spring 2025, leaving poisons they'd made, including cyanide, thallium, abrin, and hydrogen sulfide, in Bade's vehicle.
The poisonings left Bade hospitalized, ill enough that she lost her voice and her hair for months in 2025, Bade said in court, waiving her own right to privacy, in 2025.
Bade had been a friend of VanDuyne's, and is one of two people in Rock and Dane Counties VanDuyne and Whitaker poisoned.
Coming out of a two-hour hearing on Monday, Rock County Judge Derrick Grubb ruled Monday that by Dec. 4, the Rock County D.A. give Whitaker and VanDuyne's separate attorneys copies of all the text messages the D.A. says it has that it says give evidence that VanDuyne and Whitaker conspired to poison Bade.
Grubb said he'll then give VanDuyne's and Whitaker's lawyers until Dec. 28 to hand Grubb any objections to statements prosecutors intend to introduce.
Grubb said having a list of objections he can read in private will help him decide whether a joint trial would work, or if he might have to split VanDuyne and Whitaker's case into several trials.
The Rock County D.A.'s office said it preferred Grubb's ruling, because it could save time at a jury trial if some text messages in the prosecution's case drew waves of objections.
Grubb already has estimated a two-month trial in the case, which prosecutors say includes mounds of evidence. District Attorney Jason Sanders estimated the case would need a total of 200 possible jurors, a number that Grubb agreed with.
Trial is set to roll on March 29, using the court's largest courtroom.