undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
ISD 728 says classroom screen use is purposeful, not a problem
By Jim Boyle,
3 days agoISD 728 administrators say technology use in classrooms is intentional and supports instruction, and they do not believe the district has a significant screen-time problem in its schools.
That was the message Superintendent Andy Almos emphasized during a recent presentation to the school board examining how students use district-issued devices, what the district can monitor and how technology fits into classroom instruction.
“As you can see, we don’t believe there’s a lot to fix here,” Almos said. “We think the screen time is useful. Our teachers are making great decisions on when and how and why to use screen time.”
The presentation by Troy Anderson, the district’s director of instructional technology and innovation, and Joe Samek, the director of information technology, provided board members with data from September, along with information about national screen-time trends and the district’s efforts to promote digital wellness.
Almos said the district wanted to better understand and explain its practices as screen time becomes a growing topic of discussion among parents, educators and elected officials.
He said he wanted board members to understand the district’s approach before potential state mandates or other changes are considered.
“We don’t believe that we actually have an issue with screen time,” Almos said.
The discussion also made clear that administrators distinguish between technology used for learning during the school day and the much broader screen habits students develop outside school.
September data offers a starting point
The district collected data from Sept. 1-30, covering 21 instructional days. The analysis focused on students in grades 3-12 using district-issued Chromebooks and relied on GoGuardian, a tool teachers use to monitor activity on those devices.
The data showed that approximately 74% of Chromebook use occurred during the school day, with the remaining 26% occurring outside school hours. Students averaged about 23 minutes of Chromebook use per day outside school, including weekends.
The presentation showed differences by grade level. High school students averaged about 94 minutes of Chromebook use during the school day and another 35 minutes outside school. Middle school students averaged about 80 minutes during the school day.
The district hopes to continue collecting data through monthly reports, allowing administrators to examine patterns over time rather than relying on a single month.
Anderson cautioned that the numbers represent Chromebook activity, not total screen time. The analysis does not include students’ personal phones or other devices.
That limitation prompted School Board Vice-Chair Shane Steinbrecher to ask whether the data reflected differences among students receiving special education services, some of whom rely on technology as an important learning and communication tool.
Anderson and Samek explained that some students in higher special education settings use iPads because of their accessibility features. Those devices are not included in the Chromebook report.
The district also does not currently have the same level of monitoring for iPads used by younger students.
Students in kindergarten through second grade primarily use iPads, which teachers manage through Apple Classroom. That tool allows teachers to keep students focused on a particular lesson or activity, but it does not provide the same activity reporting dashboard available through GoGuardian.
Samek said the district is exploring what it would take to add more detailed monitoring of iPad activity, although doing so would involve additional costs.
Anderson said he would expect screen use among younger students to follow a similar downward trend, based on their more limited access to devices and the district’s elementary curriculum. He emphasized, however, that this was an educated guess rather than data collected through the same monitoring system.
Instruction comes first
A central theme of the presentation was that screen time should be evaluated by how technology is being used, not simply by the number of minutes students spend on a device.
Anderson discussed the American Academy of Pediatrics’ “5 Cs” framework for considering children’s media use: Child, Content, Calm, Crowding Out and Communication.
The framework encourages families and educators to consider a child’s individual needs, the content being viewed, how screens are used to manage emotions, what activities screen use may be replacing and how adults communicate with children about technology.
During board discussion, School Board Chair Mike Nordos said he appreciated that the presentation included not only the amount of time students spend on devices but also what they are doing.
He described the difference between students using technology for learning and the potentially negative effects of prolonged scrolling or online activities.
Jamie Nord, the assistant superintendent of elementary educational services, speaking specifically about elementary students, said the September data did not cause her concern about excessive screen use.
“I think we’re being really intentional about how it’s being used in instruction,” Nord said. “It’s not technology and then, oh, how does this fit with instruction? It’s instruction and how does technology enhance the instruction.”
Nord pointed to recent curriculum changes that emphasize hands-on learning rather than having students spend more time on devices.
She described a math lesson at Twin Lakes Elementary in which students used popsicle sticks and other manipulatives to learn about tally marks. The district’s Bridges in Mathematics curriculum and its use of functional phonics and morphology also emphasize explicit instruction and hands-on learning.
Kari Rock, the assistant superintendent of secondary educational services, added that technology use varies by classroom and subject. Some high school career and technical education courses, for example, involve so much hands-on work that students may not open their Chromebooks at all.
Rock said teachers recognize the importance of engaging, collaborative and project-based learning.
“What we’ve heard from our high schoolers is, everything’s here, why would I need to come to school, right?” Rock said, describing the importance of making classroom experiences interactive and giving students opportunities to work with their peers. “Kids engage best with others around them.”
Anderson also described how the district monitors Chromebook activity to discourage students from using devices for games or other unrelated activities.
He said students sometimes find ways around website restrictions, including creating their own games that do not operate through an internet site. GoGuardian has added a Smart Alerts feature that can identify patterns of activity associated with gaming and warn students or block the activity.
Anderson said the monitoring tools have improved, although some time-wasting activity still occurs.
“The majority of kids are pretty on track,” Samek said, while acknowledging that students can be creative in finding ways around restrictions.
Personal devices are harder to control
Board member Sara Weis asked what the district can do to limit access to social media, gaming and other websites on students’ personal devices while they are at school.
Samek said the district limits and manages bandwidth on its guest Wi-Fi network during school hours to keep it focused on learning. Streaming services such as Disney Plus and Netflix, along with most social networking, are blocked.
Those restrictions are loosened after about 4 p.m. to allow access for families and others attending school events.
However, students with cell phones and cellular service can turn off Wi-Fi and access the internet through their own data plans.
“And we can’t control that,” Weis said.
Samek also said a parent app offered through Blue Guardian provides families with a general summary of their child’s device use. The app does not yet provide the same detailed metrics available to district staff, but the company is working on additional capabilities.
Administrators emphasized that the district can control activity on devices it issues and can place some restrictions on personal devices using its network, but it cannot control everything students access outside school.
Nord said the district wants to partner with families rather than simply tell parents that screen time is not a school issue. She pointed to the digital wellness resources the district has made available to help parents understand and manage technology use at home.
Broader screen habits remain a concern
The district’s local data was presented alongside research showing substantial screen use among young people outside school.
A 2024 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention report cited in the presentation found that 50.4% of U.S. teens ages 12-17 reported four or more hours of daily screen time, excluding schoolwork.
The presentation also referenced a 2023 Common Sense Media study that found a median of about 4.5 hours of daily smartphone use among young people, with social media accounting for nearly two hours.
Minnesota Department of Health data from 2025 showed that more than half of high school students use technology between midnight and 5 a.m. at least once a week, while one in five do so every school night.
Those figures reflect broader technology use, not the district’s Chromebook data. The concerns include what screen use may displace, such as sleep, physical activity, reading, play and in-person interaction.
Almos said the district wants to be careful not to treat broader societal concerns as problems that schools necessarily need to solve through restrictions on classroom technology.
At the same time, Nord said the district wants to help families navigate those concerns.
“We don’t want to just pass it off and say it’s not a school issue, here you go,” she said. “Like, we want to partner.”
Continuing to evaluate technology use
Board members also asked how ISD 728 compares with other districts.
Anderson said Osseo conducted a similar analysis last year, and ISD 728’s Chromebook use was about 10 minutes higher. He cautioned that comparisons are difficult because districts may measure different devices, age groups and time periods, and may have different instructional practices.
He said relatively few districts have conducted an analysis at the same level of detail.
The district has maintained a digital wellness website since 2017-18 and has added resources for families addressing screen time and artificial intelligence.
Board member John Anderson said it was important for the board to evaluate the district’s practices and communicate to the public how screen time is being monitored.
The presentation provided a snapshot of Chromebook use, but administrators said the district will continue to examine its practices and consider whether additional monitoring tools would be useful.
For Almos, the distinction is important as conversations about screen time continue at the state and national levels: ISD 728 believes its teachers are using technology appropriately to support learning, while recognizing that students’ broader relationship with screens is a concern that requires cooperation between schools and families.