undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
A choice for UC leaders: Reinstate a 100-year-old test or solve the college readiness problem
By EdSource Commentaries,
5 days agoThe SAT turned 100 this year. Some University of California faculty want to throw a comeback party for it when it should permanently be shown the door.
California higher education is at a crossroads. Our population is shrinking for the first time in history. That means fewer high school graduates may be coming to our doors, just as the workforce demands more skills. AI is upending how we teach and how we measure learning. The very future of disciplines such as mathematics is an open question. Instead of meeting this moment, some UC faculty want to reinstate a test built for a California that no longer exists. The UC regents meet this Tuesday and Wednesday, and the decision they face will shape admissions for years.
I am a UC graduate. I have spent the past 25 years leading in California public higher education. And I can tell you that reverting to the SAT is the wrong call.
Start with the basics. Admissions tests such as the SAT have little predictive value. They are more closely correlated to family wealth than to students’ abilities to thrive in college. Demands to resume using them also disregard the UC system’s public purpose and its role as an engine for upward mobility for Californians.
And the evidence is clear: Classes admitted under test-free policies are both diverse and academically strong. Graduation and first-year persistence rates are up. In recent years, UC campuses have adopted evidence-based reforms in high-demand STEM courses, such as active learning, course redesign and additional support. “Research has shown that these approaches can improve outcomes for all students while reducing disparities in course success,” the system reported.
Are some students arriving underprepared in math? Faculty are right to raise the question, which deserves a serious look at the many factors driving it. But that is no argument for returning to past policies. Retreat is not a strategy.
Worse, to argue for admissions tests, some faculty are resorting to irresponsible narratives and exposing ugly biases. Claims that students with pseudonyms such as Diego and Elias can’t succeed in college math, or that the university can admit only one Black student from a low-income neighborhood, are neither evidence-based nor accurate. Frankly, this is thinly veiled racism. It has no place in our classrooms, on our campuses or in our public debate.
UC San Diego’s oft-cited report on students’ math preparation is similarly marred by errors and omissions. It notes an increase in students placed into remedial math courses but leaves out the campus decisions that helped drive it. From 2019 to 2025, freshman classes increased by around 30%. During that time, the campus stopped allowing students to use calculators on the placement exam and raised the threshold to place into precalculus. Of course remedial placements went up. The campus all but guaranteed it.
That same faculty report put the blame for rising remedial enrollments on students from schools with high proportions of low-income, English learner and foster youth. Remedial enrollments were rising even in years when enrollment of such students was falling. More importantly, why do we blame students before we look at ourselves?
UC leaders need an honest accounting of where student preparation stands and why. There is no evidence that the current test-free policy — which I supported as a regent when it was adopted in 2020 — caused the problem. Pandemic-induced learning loss, social media, AI use, and math teacher shortages are all major contributors.
It is perplexing that a faculty so proud of its research would ignore the evidence and the innovation happening across the state, as highlighted in Just Equations’ recent series, “Voices on Math Readiness.” Look at Cuyamaca College, where a group of faculty developed a calculus course with co-requisite support. Since offering the course in 2023, the college has tracked increased completion of Calculus I and II, especially among students of color, and growing enrollment in STEM majors. Those faculty did not wait for better-prepared students to show up. They built a course for the students they have. That is what centering students looks like.
The regents will not face this decision alone. The Becerra administration will inherit this challenge, giving them an opportunity to champion the students that UC exists to serve over the laziness and racism that threatens to hold us all back.
Rather than follow a 100-year-old path that focuses on gatekeeping, we can unlock new gateways to a productive future for the next generation of Californians. It is time to look forward and build the brilliance of the future.
•••
Eloy Ortiz Oakley, president and CEO of the College Futures Foundation, is a UC regent emeritus and former chancellor of the California Community Colleges.
EdSource receives funding from many foundations, including the College Futures Foundation. EdSource maintains sole editorial control over the content of its coverage.
The opinions expressed in this commentary are those of the author. EdSource welcomes commentaries representing diverse points of view. If you would like to submit a commentary, please review our guidelines and contact us at commentary@edsource.org.
This story was originally published by EdSource.