undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Peshtigo

SOH20 member dissatisfied with PFAS settlement

By JIM PAUL EagleHerald,

2026-06-09

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=1suIr2_1CBlkfEH00

MARINETTE — Save our Water (SOH20) member and long-time PFAS advocate Doug Oitzinger says the state’s $10 million settlement with Tyco Fire Products leaves hundreds of town of Peshtigo residents effectively “on the wrong side of the wall” when it comes to clean water and long-term protection.

Oitzinger, who along with other SOH20 members, attended a private briefing with Attorney General Josh Kaul before last week’s press conference, said his initial reaction was mild compared to how he felt after reading the agreement in full.

“We knew we were disappointed, I use the term underwhelmed,” Oitzinger said of the briefing. “But then, we had a chance to take the document home and study it and we really felt we were deeply disappointed, this has got some stuff in it that we really do not like.”

At the center of SOH20’s criticism is the Expanded Site Investigation Area (ESIA) — a broad swath of land south of Marinette. The Department of Natural Resources has long argued that Tyco is responsible for PFAS contamination there; the company has consistently denied it.

Oitzinger says the settlement effectively ends that standoff in Tyco’s favor.

“This settlement agreement basically cuts the legs out from under the DNR and says no more, the DNR will no longer require you to investigate this area,” Oitzinger said.

Residents in that ESIA, he noted, already have documented PFAS in their wells, with the state — and taxpayers — footing the bill for testing and bottled water.

Unlike households in areas Tyco accepts as its responsibility, those in the expanded area have not been offered replacement wells, point-of-entry treatment systems or long-term bottled water.

“It is almost like the Berlin Wall,” Oitzinger said. “On the one side you have things being provided and on the other side nothing.”

The settlement directs Tyco’s $10 million payment into the state’s PFAS trust fund, not specifically to Marinette and the town of Peshtigo. Kaul told residents they would have to push to ensure that money is reserved for the local contamination tied to Tyco’s Fire Technology Center.

Oitzinger called the amount inadequate, especially spread over years of cleanup and replacement wells.

“These deep wells, it is $80,000 for a deep well and you have got $10 million,” Oitzinger said. “It is not going to cover all of the things that will need to be done over the next 20 years.”

He also blasted provisions that sharply limit who qualifies for a new well and how long bottled water or in-home filtration will be provided if homeowners decline a well, saying the terms are skewed towards Tyco.

The agreement leans heavily on Tyco’s groundwater extraction and treatment (GET) system, which captures contaminated groundwater before it reaches drainage ditches that flow into the Bay of Green Bay.

Oitzinger said that system may help protect the bay but will do little for most private well owners.

“If you go not even two blocks to the south, north or two blocks to the east, the extraction system will not treat one drop of water,” Oitzinger said. “If you have contaminated groundwater under your house in the town of Peshtigo today, you will have contaminated groundwater under your house 20 years from now.”

Oitzinger also revisited the legal basis of the lawsuit noting Tyco discovered massive PFAS levels in groundwater at its Fire Technology Center in 2013 and retested in 2014 but did not report the contamination to the DNR until 2016. The public, he said, did not learn of it until late 2017.

“For the folks on private wells in the town of Peshtigo, they continued to drink this poison for four years after you discovered it,” Oitzinger said.

The settlement contains no medical component, something Oitzinger said residents had hoped for but were told could not be included.

With a Brown County judge already approving the agreement, Oitzinger said the focus of SOH20 now shifts to advocacy, pressing the DNR to reserve the full $10 million for the Marinette and town of Peshtigo area. Still he said the scale of the settlement speaks volumes.

“You pay your CEO twice as much as you are going to settle this situation in Marinette and Peshtigo,” Otizinger said, calling the deal “not enough” for a community that has lived with PFAS for nearly a decade.

Comments