undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
UHSAA prepares to unveil historic 2027-29 realignment using new data-driven index
By James Edward,
4 days agoWhen the UHSAA board of trustees convenes Thursday morning, high schools across Utah will get their first look at where they’ll likely land for the 2027-2029 athletics calendar.
This cycle introduces a major overhaul — an effort by the UHSAA to level the competitive playing field. Rather than basing classifications almost exclusively on enrollment numbers, it will place schools using a single, data-driven metric: the Competitive Realignment Index (CRI).
The CRI index factors in athletic success, socioeconomic factors and enrollment.
“Realignment will never produce a perfect solution for every school,” UHSAA executive director Ryan Bishop said in a statement previously. “Utah is growing and changing, and our schools vary greatly in enrollment, geography and circumstances. Our responsibility is to work through our member-driven governance process and establish classifications and regions that provide the best opportunity possible for fair and equitable competition across the state.”
At Thursday’s meeting, the board will review blind CRI scores — with school names removed — to lock in the exact formula weights and establish initial class placement. Under the provisional general formula, enrollment accounts for 77% of a school’s score, while socioeconomic status carries 13% — outweighing on-field competitive results at 10%.
Trustees have the option to nudge those percentages slightly during the blind review if adjusting creates cleaner breaks in the CRI data between classifications.
One major change already confirmed is the expansion of Class 6A. While 6A currently operates with just 17 teams, the UHSAA has mandated that 6A, 5A and 4A must all have at least 21 schools in the new alignment, while 3A, 2A and 1A require a minimum of eight.
Beyond that, there is no predetermined amount of teams in any classification. Instead, board members will examine the blind CRI to look for gaps between teams to draw the classification lines.
Despite the introduction of the new CRI index, winning alone won’t push a smaller school up a classification unless its student body is already large.
While the exact competitive index numbers won’t be revealed until Thursday, looking at the results from the Deseret News High School Sports All-Sports Award over the past three school years — the time frame the UHSAA will use — offers a glimpse at how the index may shake out.
Paired with prior UHSAA enrollment figures from two years ago, programs like Maple Mountain, Brighton, Olympus, Bountiful and Skyline in 5A, and Crimson Cliffs and Ridgeline in 4A, sit right in the mix of high enrollment, favorable socioeconomic metrics and strong multisport performance to potentially move up on Thursday.
Once initial classifications are unveiled on Nov. 19, schools still have options before regions are finalized. Like in past cycles, schools may apply after the first draft to move up into a higher classification — either as an entire athletic program, similar to Corner Canyon opting into 6A across all sports, or in individual sports, such as Orem playing up in football and Highland playing up in boys basketball.
Conversely, schools can no longer appeal their placement simply based on competitive struggles; geography and travel are the sole criteria for an appeal.
When geography is an issue, the board of trustees may grant an exception and move a school down a full classification — or keep a school in a lower classification for region play but require it to compete in its higher classification during state tournaments. These scenarios could play out if schools like Crimson Cliffs or Ridgeline find themselves getting bumped up to 5A in the new CRI.
Inside the math: How the CRI works
Under the new format, every school receives a single composite Z-score on a continuous scale ranging from -2.08 to +1.16, built from three cores:
- Enrollment size (provisional 77% weight): Classifications are anchored by Oct. 1 enrollment counts for 10th and 11th grade students, excluding self-contained special education students and districtwide alternative school enrollments. According to the UHSAA, the combined sophomore and junior total is log-scaled so that the gap between a 300- and 600-student school carries the same statistical weight as the gap between 1,200 and 2,400.
- Socioeconomic status (provisional 13% weight): Derived from Utah State Board of Education data on economically disadvantaged students (K-12), the SES metric carries more weight than competitive performance and acts as a direct counterweight to raw enrollment.
- Competitive results (provisional 10% weight): Rather than relying solely on RPI rankings from a few major team sports, the CRI averages three seasons of performance (2023-24, 2024-25 and 2025-26) across all 25 UHSAA-sanctioned sports and activities. Schools are judged year-by-year against the classification they competed in, and if a school does not field a team in a given sport, it is excluded from that calculation rather than penalized with a zero.
“Socioeconomic data has been included as part of past alignments, typically applied to bubble schools near classification thresholds,” Bishop said. “This cycle builds that same factor directly into a unified index for all schools.”
To calculate the competitive pillar, the UHSAA splits its 25 activities into two categories:
- The 10 PSR sports: Basketball, soccer, volleyball and lacrosse, plus baseball and softball. Each uses its postseason ranking (a combination of MaxPreps power rankings and RPI) multiplied by a state tournament placement multiplier ranging from 1.0 to 1.8.
- The 15 placement sports: Cross country, wrestling, track, golf, tennis and swimming, along with competitive cheer and drill team. These are scored on a 1-to-6 scale based on state meet finishes (6 points for a state title down to 1 point for competing without placing).
Potential bubble schools
To see which programs face the biggest squeeze heading into Thursday’s blind draw, it helps to compare Deseret News All-Sports standings over the UHSAA’s three-year evaluation window. These are the top five athletic schools over the past three years who could get a boost if their enrollments and socioeconomic metrics sit near the cut line:
- Class 5A: Olympus, Maple Mountain, Timpview, Skyline, Brighton and Bountiful.
Because both 5A and 4A already have well over 21 schools in the current alignment, there is no guarantee teams will automatically shuffle up or down — everything depends on how large Class 6A grows beyond its 21-team floor and where the clean breaks fall in the blind CRI scores.
At least four 5A programs have to move up to fill out 6A, creating a tug-of-war between enrollment giants like Granger (1,649 upperclassmen in 2024), Taylorsville (1,306) and Cyprus (1,301) — whose CRI scores take a steep downward pull from the 13% socioeconomic factor and minimal athletic success — and high-enrollment, strong All-Sports schools like Maple Mountain (1,214 upperclassmen), Brighton (1,193) and Timpview (1,193).
Right behind them sits a tightly bunched cluster led by 5A’s top non-football All-Sports performer, Olympus, alongside Skyline, Pleasant Grove and Bountiful — meaning a clean mathematical break around 23 or 24 teams in 6A could pull several of them upward together.
- Class 4A: Ridgeline, Desert Hills, Park City, Orem, Crimson Cliffs and Snow Canyon.
Even if 5A loses four to six teams to 6A, it already has enough teams to stay above the 21-school minimum without automatically pulling teams up from 4A — meaning a clean mathematical break in the CRI data could keep 4A largely intact.
Still, if the board draws the 5A/4A cut line slightly lower, Crimson Cliffs (946 upperclassmen in 2024) and Ridgeline (897) sit right on the bubble near the top of 4A in both enrollment and multisport success, alongside Park City, whose socioeconomic score and dominance in lacrosse, swimming and golf push its CRI upward despite a smaller enrollment.
- Class 3A: Morgan, Canyon View, Union, Richfield, Ogden and Grantsville/Juab.
No two schools in Utah have dominated their class quite like Morgan and Canyon View. However, both had significantly smaller enrollments two years ago (571 and 525, respectively) than the smallest 4A schools (Ogden 780) and Mountain Crest (784) as well as larger 3A programs like Cedar City (727) and Logan (683). Under the 77% enrollment weight, bridging a 200-student gap into 4A remains a tall order.
- Class 2A: North Summit, South Sevier, Rowland Hall, Millard, Beaver and Grand County.
- Class 1A: Panguitch, Rich, Monticello, Milford, Valley and Wayne/Tabiona.
In 2A, North Summit, South Sevier and Rowland Hall led the three-year non-football All-Sports standings, while Panguitch (12 straight All-Sports titles) and Rich dominate 1A. Because 1A and 2A schools carry much smaller enrollments than the classes above them, high competitive and socioeconomic scores alone may not pull them upward unless the board draws a break that shifts the smallest classifications.
Football runs on its own track
Football never enters the general CRI calculation. Instead, football classifications — including eight-player — run on a separate index that leans even heavier on school size. Under the provisional weights proposed for Thursday’s meeting, the football CRI is calculated at 85% enrollment, 8% SES and 7% competitive performance.
Just as in the general alignment, the board can adjust those percentages slightly on Thursday to find clean mathematical breaks in the football scores, ensuring at least 21 programs land in 6A, 5A and 4A, and at least eight in 3A, 2A, 1A and eight-player.
What comes next
The Nov. 19 meeting marks the first of four steps before the 2027-2029 alignment is finalized:
- Nov. 19: Initial classification placement and first consideration of member schools.
- Dec. 1: Second consideration of classifications, review of geographic appeals and requests to play up, and first consideration of assigned regions.
- Dec. 8: Public hearing via Zoom.
- Dec. 9: Second consideration of assigned regions.
- Dec. 17: Final approval and establishment of the 2027-2029 realignment.
Competition under the new alignment will officially begin in August 2027.