undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Where St. Helens stands in active lawsuits
By Kaelyn Cassidy,
11 days agoSt. Helens has been sued multiple times in recent years, and some lawsuits are still ongoing.
The city is involved in active litigation over public records, issues with its former events contractor and claims of retaliation against its former police chief.
Here’s where the city stands in open cases:
Contempt of court in public records lawsuit
The city has been ordered to pay more than $50,000 in fees after it was found to be in contempt of court for disobeying a judge’s orders to produce certain records in an ongoing lawsuit.
Let’s rewind: In June 2025, Jennifer Myrick — a public defender who previously represented former St. Helens High School teacher Eric Stearns in a sexual abuse case — filed a lawsuit against the city.
• The lawsuit is related to a records request Myrick made. In February 2025, she filed a request to the city stating, “I would like all records and information regarding myself. I request copies of bodycam and all communications, reports, and investigations containing my name or reference to me.”
• Myrick’s lawsuit alleges the city did not fully comply with public records laws by failing to disclose all records responsive to her request and not giving a proper explanation for why it was exempting or redacting some records. Myrick also accused the city of charging too much to produce the records in order to obstruct access to them after she was quoted more than $4,200 for the fulfillment of the request.
• Myrick’s complaint states that she is seeking these records due to “ongoing harassment by the Saint Helens Police Department, threats of criminal prosecution, and misrepresentations by officers.”
Since then: Myrick and the city have been involved in a brutal back-and-forth in court in which the city has repeatedly argued against the breadth of Myrick’s requests — which include inspection of officers’ personal cellphones. The judge has disagreed and issued orders to comply.
• After missing multiple deadlines to provide requested records and a log detailing documents the city exempted or redacted, St. Helens was found to be in contempt of court.
• As a result, the city was ordered to pay Myrick more than $50,000 in fees — $500 for each day after the deadline the city did not provide the records or the exemption log. The fees continue to accrue, Myrick said. The city must also pay Myrick more than $64,000 in attorney fees, about $20,500 of which will go to Myrick and approximately $43,500 to her co-counsel.
Underlying issues: Clashes between Myrick and St. Helens Police Chief Matt Smith have appeared as an undercurrent in the case throughout the year-and-a-half of public records litigation. Two specific incidents have come up repeatedly:
• The first relates to the Stearns case. As SHPD officers attempted to arrest Stearns for the second time Jan. 4, 2025, a group text thread between officers showed Myrick was involved in negotiating Stearns’ surrender. An officer sent a message stating that he called Stearns’ wife, who told the officer that Myrick also called her to tell her not to talk to police, according to court documents.
• Smith, who was not the chief of police at the time, appears to reply, “That’s Hindering Prosecution!” and stating that Myrick doesn’t represent Stearns’ wife.
• The officer responds to Smith, stating, “Want us to go arrest Myrick? :)” before the thread moves on to discuss other details of the arrest.
• The other incident stems from a case Myrick represented in 2023. Two months after Myrick filed her records request to the city in February 2025, Smith submitted a complaint to the Oregon State Bar alleging that Myrick stole a cellphone from a witness in the 2023 case.
• According to Smith’s complaint, the witness told SHPD officers that Myrick came to the witness’s home with two private investigators who allegedly identified themselves as law enforcement. The phone was taken during this visit.
• Smith states that he investigated the incident and referred the case to the Yamhill County District Attorney’s Office for prosecution, which declined to file criminal charges.
• In response to Smith’s complaint, Myrick denied Smith’s allegations of misconduct and claimed Smith was retaliating against her for filing a complaint against him with the Oregon Department of Public Safety Standards and Training and for her records request.
• “I filed this public records request to determine just how far Matt Smith has gone,” Myrick said in her response to Smith’s complaint.
• The bar did not find that Myrick had engaged in misconduct.
Lawsuit still ongoing: The public records lawsuit is still ongoing, and the judge recently ordered a third-party reviewer be brought in to verify the city’s compliance with records requests. A trial is currently set for Nov. 19.
Not the city’s first public records lawsuit: The city of St. Helens recently paid Mayor-elect Steve Toschi $81,000 to settle another public records dispute involving documents related to 2024-25 tumult in the St. Helens Police Department.
Events contractor lawsuit moved to federal court
The lawsuit filed against St. Helens by its former events contractor will now be heard in federal court.
Background: Longtime city events organizer Tina Cannard, also known as Tina Curry, sued the city for nearly $2.5 million in damages in July.
• Cannard made a number of allegations against the city, including defamation and a breach of contract related to being cut off from a Wauna Credit Union bank account that was used to manage profits and expenses for St. Helens events.
Why has the case been moved to federal court?: In addition to the city, the lawsuit names City Councilor Brandon Sundeen and current and former St. Helens chiefs of police Matt Smith and Brian Greenway as defendants. Cannard alleges Sundeen, Smith and Greenway violated her Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment rights.
• Federal courts have jurisdiction over disputes arising out of alleged constitutional violations, prompting the case to be moved.
Former police chief’s lawsuit still ongoing
The lawsuit brought against the city by former chief of police Joseph Hogue is still being litigated.
What is the case about?: In March 2025, Hogue filed a lawsuit against the city and Mayor Jennifer Massey claiming he’d been blocked from a permanent role as chief of police in an apparent act of retaliation for reporting Greenway for alleged misconduct.
• Both Massey and the city have moved to dismiss the lawsuit. The judge has denied both motions to dismiss.
• Massey has appealed the judge’s denial of her motion to dismiss on grounds that her actions are protected under a state law designed to prevent frivolous lawsuits that seek to deter individuals from exercising their First Amendment rights to free speech — Commonly referred to as SLAPP lawsuits, or Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation.
Editor’s note: This story has been updated to add that contempt of court fees continue to accrue against St. Helens.