All products featured on Vogue are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Among editorial pros like makeup artist Raoúl Alejandre, the Valentino Twin Eyeliner has been a best-kept secret for mesmerizing winged eyes. But now it’s finally having its moment in the sun, thanks to TikTok and its reigning queen of makeup, Mikayla Nogueira. “It glides; it’s precise,” the 24-year-old proclaimed as she traced on a set of graphic flicks with the ease of a skilled calligrapher. “This is my new favorite.” Of course, there’s no higher accolade than a rave from Nogueira, but being a cat-eye obsessive, I had to try it myself.