There came a point when Erin Krakow knew she wanted to work with Tyler Hynes, a charismatic fan-favorite among the Hallmark set. So when it came time to find the perfect leading man for her to play off of in Hallmark Channel's latest romance, It Was Always You, the When Calls the Heart star had one person in mind. "People really love Tyler and they're excited to see him. I was excited to work, then actually requested him for this movie because I thought he'd be so great in this part," Krakow told ET, which Hynes confirmed. "She expressed that to me, which, I'm not sure exactly why she did that," he humbly said. "I'm very thankful she did because we had a very nice time. Erin's an incredible human being and a very, very talented actor."