undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
La Pointe

La Pointe ends ferry operator's contract, will run Madeline Island Ferry Line itself

By Rick Olivo,

2 days ago

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=2FXLGC_1HF1OFJl00

The town of La Pointe, which owns the Madeline Island Ferry Line, has terminated its contract with the private company that operates the ferry between Bayfield and La Pointe, effective Dec. 28.

The action comes with more than a year left on the four-year contract with the operating company, Madeline Island Ferry Line LLC. The town has owned the ferry line since March 2024, when it closed on the purchase of the line's assets for about $17.3 million. La Pointe Town Board Chair Glenn Carlson said the town intends to take over day-to-day operations itself.

"There was always in the agreement a provision for early termination, and the town concluded that it was in its interests not to wait until the end of the contract," he said.

Carlson said waiting until the end of the contract to take over the operation would involve much more uncertainty for everyone involved.

"We've long thought that as the owner we should also have the operational abilities," he said. "This is not terribly unlike what the Bayfield Harbor Commission did a few years ago when they parted ways with the outside manager that they had hired to operate the marina."

Carlson said the town is not alleging any breach of contract by MIFL LLC, but said the termination was intended to protect the town's interests.

"The longer that we continue with this management agreement with this outside firm, the more embedded they become and the more difficult it becomes to negotiate with them down the road," he said. "Rather than continuing to feed the beast, if you will, we just said we think we can do this."

Carlson said that during a six-month transition period, Shannon Mager of Apostle Islands Cruises would serve as a consultant to the La Pointe Harbor Commission, which the town created to buy the ferry line, for a fee of $10,000 a month. He noted that Mager, general manager of Apostle Islands Cruises, is an 18-year veteran of the ferry line. He said Katie Kisner, the Harbor Commission's current full-time staff member, would serve as its chief administrative officer for the ferry line.

The town currently pays MIFL LLC a management fee of $250,000 a year in addition to reasonable operating expenses, Carlson said. Under the contract's early termination provision, the firm will also be paid the $250,000 fee for next year.

MIFL LLC President and owner Cal Linehan said he still does not know why the town canceled the contract with his firm.

"In fact I have asked for that. The best that I have been told to answer that question is that they have wanted to move into direct management themselves and there has been some back and forth on that. At the meeting where they announced this vote they said that it had been something they have been contemplating for about a year," he said.

Linehan said that when the town decided to terminate the contract, the ferry line had been running smoothly.

"They are running great. We are under budget. We are arriving on time. There are always going to be complaints, as far as not being able to get everything perfect, but there has been nothing new that has come up in recent years that has changed as far as operations are concerned," he said. "In fact, we just proposed expanding the schedule for 2027, adding additional trips. We've been under budget, doing a really good job and we've got a really talented crew."

Linehan said the ferry line has been running in the black, and that at the last Harbor Commission meeting, officials announced a significant projected budget surplus that would allow the town to pay off some of its debt sooner than anticipated.

"So I am not aware of any specific reason outside of them having said that they want direct control," he said. "The timing of it was a pretty big surprise."

Linehan said that because nothing has happened yet, he is uncertain how the termination will affect employees.

"At this stage it is all speculative. Pretty much all of the staff was not expecting this, we had a year left on our contract. I think they definitely want to see all of the benefits, cleanly laid out, what are their plans, and at this time, it's only been a couple of weeks so we don't have all of that information available," he said.

He said he is encouraging employees to do what is in their best interests.

"If they want to go and work for the town, that is what they should do," he said.

Linehan said he has no immediate personal plans.

"My objective is to finish up the month and a half we have remaining, just make sure I am doing the best possible job as we always have," he said.

There have been reports of anxiety among current ferry employees about their future with the end of the MIFL LLC contract, but Carlson said the town intends to keep all current ferry line employees.

"They will become town employees, which is actually going to be a better thing for them; they get access to the state retirement system, the state health plan," Carlson said, adding that the jobs would also be more secure.

Carlson said he was concerned by the reported unease among ferry line employees.

"It troubles me a great deal," he said. "Unfortunately, given our contractual obligations with MIFL LLC, it was required to have a unanimous vote of the Harbor Commission, and that only occurred about 10 days ago, so everyone is surprised and I would be too. I do feel badly for the employees."

He said employees have about 60 days' notice to adjust to working for the town instead of a private company.

Nevertheless, Carlson said he believes there is a good transition ahead for employees.

"We've given every possible assurance that we can that they are going to carry over, that their vacations accrued is going to carry over, their seniority, they are going to keep benefits that town employees don't even get. We are trying to bend over backwards to make sure that the employees realize that this is actually going to be a good thing for them," he said.

One employee who has not made up her mind is MIFL executive assistant Ariadana Chediack.

"It is quite a change, and we are not sure yet what is going to happen, which way it's going," she said. "I don't know what I am going to do yet; I am still balancing my ideas, and there are some things that are not clear yet."

Ferry captain Mike Parsons, who has been with the ferry line for 13 years, said he too is uncertain about the future for himself and the rest of the ferry line personnel.

"Change is always hard. They changed hands a couple of years ago and everything went smoothly, and I imagine the same transition from the LLC to the town is coming. Some people are nervous, some excited," he said. "Time will tell on all this."

Parsons said the most important thing for the town to consider as it takes control of the ferry line is being open to any questions or concerns the crew might have.

"They should be transparent with everything. I think that will be a good thing," he said.

Parsons said the town has done a good job so far and cited Kisner as an effective source of information.

"I think employees are coming into this with an open mind, and with everything we have seen so far, she is great. I think it's going to go very well, and I'm hoping for the best," he said.

emoji_wow
emoji_like
2

Comments