undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Sumter County Administrator explains switch to more expensive ambulance service
By Joshua Windus,
2025-12-20It was brought to the attention of the Americus Times-Recorder that Sumter County did not choose the lowest bid when selecting an emergency management service to provide ambulances for the County. With the new emergency medical service (EMS) fees put in place, many have expressed concerns about the added expense.
County Administrator Scott Carver gave explanations for the new fees and the switch to a more expensive EMS service in a recent interview.
Carver said the County decided that creating the EMS fee would be a better choice than raising property taxes to fund ambulance services for the County. “A millage increase would place the entire cost solely on property owners, even though EMS demand comes from people, not fields or trees.”
The fee varies depending on the structures on the property, with many homes paying the base $75 fee. Recent court rulings state that the fees must be proportional to use. “Because larger buildings and gathering places typically serve more people and experience more EMS activity, the County added a small square-footage factor to keep the structure equitable, reasonable, and legally compliant.”
The County also switched from its old EMS service provider, Gold Star EMS, to AmeriPro. Gold Star placed a bid of $834,000 to provide services for the County. The County went with AmeriPro, which bid $1,146,709.92. Carver explained that the reason was to ensure proper service. “Gold Star previously contracted with Sumter County to provide three advanced life support (ALS) ambulances at all times. In practice, they frequently provided less than 3 properly staffed ambulances. However, due to no protection in the contract, the County was still required to pay for 3 ALS ambulances.”
President of Gold Star EMS, Charles Proctor, said that they met the terms of their contract by providing three ambulances staffed with Advanced Life Support personnel. “In Georgia, an advanced EMT and a basic EMT would satisfy that ALS requirement. Even with that in the contract, Gold Star EMS actually employed 1 paramedic on every ambulance at our own expense, and if for some reason the paramedic was not on duty, their position would have been filled by an advanced EMT to cover that part of the contract.”
Proctor seemed to indicate that they rarely deviated from this practice. “Not having ALS staff on duty likely never happened the way it has been described. If this were correct, these situations were NEVER uncovered by our managers and internal dispatchers or ever raised to our attention by the 911 center who dispatches the emergencies and would have had to assign Gold Star calls to another county or the fire departments. Gold Star was never informed by the Sumter Board of Commissioners who would be in communication with the citizens, hospital and fire departments.”
The Americus Times-Recorder published an article on its website on August 22, 2022, “Gold Star EMS Director Charles Proctor explains to Sumter County Board of Commissioners the alleged lack of ambulance service back on August 1 of this year.” In the article, Proctor responded to a complaint that there was no ambulance available for a patient when a request to transfer the patient from Phoebe Sumter’s intensive care unit to one in Albany was made by the patient’s family. Proctor said that in that particular instance it was considered a non-emergency call, since it came from family and not Phoebe Sumter Medical Center.
Proctor stated the ambulance was from the non-emergency service that operates out of Albany, and not the County’s 911 service. “We have a two-hour response time to get that patient moved, and it goes into the system, and that ambulance gets dispatched,” Proctor said.
The article also stated that in that specific instance, one Commissioner was satisfied that the EMS service was not to blame. “When you went back and you looked and you told me you looked at your logs, you did not get a call from Phoebe Sumter till 10:30 p.m., so you were inside your two-hour window,” Commissioner Jim Reid told Proctor.
Proctor still argues that their services have proper oversight, since violations can be reported to the Georgia Office of Emergency Services, which governs ambulance services. “There was never a formal complaint about Gold Star EMS in Sumter County (or any other county) from our first day of operation in Americus on August 1st 2014, to our last day on June 31st 2025.”
He addressed the County’s claims of insufficient staffing. “This comment must have been an isolated situation with staff being sick or ill, or family members being sick or ill until a replacement arrived.”
He argued that any shortages were unavoidable. “In the event there ever was not an ambulance available, it was likely due to all three Sumter contracted units [being] on a call at the same time, transporting Sumter County emergency patients to area hospitals, or they were assisting the surrounding counties with mutual aid, due to their ambulances being out of their county on an emergency.”
Proctor also said they had originally performed the service for free. “Gold Star provided EMS coverage [for] Sumter County for the first seven years at no cost (zero dollars) from 2014 to 2021. We only requested a subsidy after COVID due to the increased cost of equipment and staff.”
However, Carver states that the County went in a different direction, viewing AmeriPro as a better fit to ensure the safety of citizens. He said that having a paramedic onboard is essential, since emergency medical technician-basic (EMT-B), emergency medical technician-intermediate (EMT-I), and emergency medical technician-advanced (EMT-A) providers cannot administer critical medications and many life-saving measures.
Carver explained the County’s reasons for selecting AmeriPro EMS. “When Sumter County issued a Request for Proposals (RFP) for our ambulance service, four companies submitted bids. Although AmeriPro EMS was not the lowest bidder, they were selected because they demonstrated the strongest combination of experience, reliability, staffing stability, and accountability. The decision was based on documented performance, references, and the long-term need to protect residents through dependable emergency response.”
Carver argues AmeriPro’s higher cost was worth the expense, giving a history of meeting staffing requirements and a guarantee that a paramedic will be onboard all ambulances. There is also a clause in their contract requiring AmeriPro to provide a credit for the cost of any service if they fail to provide it.
Correction: An earlier version of this article said that EMS fees stood for emergency management service fees. The correct acronym is emergency medical service fees.