undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Editorial: Taxpayers still being denied information
By Crystal Stevenson,
2 days agoThe secretary of Louisiana Economic Development continues to defend the use of nondisclosure agreements when attracting industry to the state. Those agreements are also called confidentiality agreements or secrecy agreements — and are a legally binding contract that creates a confidential relationship between two or more parties.
NDAs legally bar the receiving party from sharing or misusing proprietary data, such as trade secrets, client lists, business plans, formulas, or financial data.
Those agreements were widely used to attract the $50 billion Meta data center named Hyperion to Richland Parish and the SpaceX $100 billion spaceport to Vermilion Parish.
The Center Square reported that Susan Bourgeois, LED secretary, said the agency will continue using nondisclosure agreements despite objections from the public and even other state officials.
“At this point, it’s very much stay the course because I think the results are bearing some pretty significant fruit here,” Bourgeois said during a webinar hosted by the Public Affairs Research Council of Louisiana.
Bourgeois also acknowledged during the webinar that public infrastructure supporting major developments can carry significant costs for the state.
“In some cases, in many cases, because it’s public infrastructure, the state’s going to have a significant share of that,” she said. Bourgeois added that companies also contribute to road construction and maintenance.
However, she did not specify the respective public and private costs involved in that road construction and maintenance. And since the two projects are already here, that is information that the public deserves to know.
Agreements obtained by The Center Square restrict disclosure of a broad range of information, including environmental, legal and regulatory matters.
Bourgeois acknowledged that some legislators have sought to rescind their confidentiality agreements. She attributed some of those decisions to public pressure, saying lawmakers had given her that explanation.
The Center Square said other public officials have made more dissenting remarks about the agreements, including Lt. Gov. Billy Nungesser.
Nungesser has questioned whether the public has enough information to assess those commitments. In an interview with Gulf States Newsroom’s, he said officials should disclose the incentives and long-term obligations associated with projects once deals are signed.
“The balance of what we give away and what we get should be made public,” Nungesser said. He questioned whether the resulting tax revenue would cover demands on schools, roads, drainage and water systems.
When some legislators questioned projects, Bourgeois said LED responded by offering them the opportunity to sign those agreements, which allow them to participate in confidential discussions.
“The more people who are under NDAs, the more people are aware of and helping us negotiate the project,” Bourgeois said.
Fox 8 News reported that key concerns of watchdogs and residents have focused on massive electricity and water demand, new power plant and transmission line buildouts, rising housing costs, and transparency around utility agreements.
The forgotten people in these instances are the taxpayers of Louisiana who finance local, regional and state government operations. As Nungesser said, they deserve to know more about what the state is giving away and what it is getting.