undefined

Posts

undefined

Followers

User since undefined NaN
Alameda

Analysis: Mayor, Council Spar Over Surf Pool Process

By Irene Dieter,

22 hours ago

The idea of a surf pool facility at Alameda Point has drawn support since it was introduced at an open house in May 2025, but not necessarily for locating it in Enterprise Park. The 21-acre triangle-shaped park stretches from the Encinal Boat Ramp to the ferry maintenance facility. Surf pools can generate rideable waves on demand.

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=0AHzpx_1HAj0pf200
Enterprise Park with the proposed surf pool facility footprint outlined, from the City’s presentation at the November 4 workshop. Map by the City of Alameda.

On November 4, City Manager Gerry Beaudin sought direction from City Council on the controversial topic. Options at the workshop boiled down to sticking to one developer’s proposal, opening a competitive bidding process, considering a different location for the surf pool, or postponing a decision until the new Council establishes its 2027 priorities and funding.

City Council chose to move forward with preparing an exclusive negotiating agreement (ENA) with surf pool developer Neptune Beach Surf Club Development Partners to obtain a park master plan paid for by Neptune, which could result in having an outdoor surf pool in the park. Mayor Marilyn Ezzy Ashcraft dissented, but her efforts toward a different outcome ended up dovetailing with Beaudin’s reasoning on the next steps.

An ENA allows only one prospective developer to work with the City to evaluate a project and agree on the terms before consummating a development agreement. There are no available funds set aside to implement the eventual park master plan, except for the investor funds for a surf pool facility.

Recreation and Parks Department Director Justin Long explained that the City-led park master plan process would explore alternatives and determine whether the proposed surf pool concept aligns with the community vision. Then an environmental review would take place.

Public comment

Comments shared by public attendees at the workshop echoed views that have been expressed since the project was first introduced. Most commenters supported locating the project in the commercial district to preserve the park’s peaceful character. Some supported the proposal’s economic development potential, noting that the area is underutilized. And others said that the City’s visioning process is designed to favor a single developer rather than ensure fair, competitive bidding.

“Entering into an exclusive negotiating agreement at this point is premature,” said resident Linda Carloni, identifying the key controversies. “We don’t know if this is the best developer” or “if it is the highest and best use for the park.” She added that “having the developer fund the park master plan,” with a vested interest in the outcome, has “an appearance of impropriety.”

Developers comment

City Council also heard from the applicant Neptune and from another developer who is interested in building a surf pool at Alameda Point.

William Duncanson, Neptune’s project sponsor, said Enterprise Park is clearly the best location for Neptune’s vision, which “is more than a commercial operation.” He explained that they seek “to leverage our investment to improve access and amenities” for park users and “to uplift our neighbors with collaborative programming and improved infrastructure.”

Thomas Lochtefeld, CEO of SurfLoch, questioned the ENA process. He explained that he has made several attempts to be considered as a developer. After reciting his surf park expertise, he advocated for putting the ENA aside and exploring options for a surf pool facility at other locations at Alameda Point, such as in a large indoor facility like Hangar 41, for year-round use.

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=31UB1n_1HAj0pf200
Building 41 Hangar, 650 West Tower Avenue, Alameda Point. Photo by Irene Dieter.

As previously reported in the Alameda Post, the City has been sidelining Lochtefeld’s offers, apparently at City Council’s direction in closed session.

After two-thirds of the 21 public speakers raised concerns about the process or the proposed location of the pool, Mayor Ashcraft started the Council deliberations.

Council discussion

“Where I start and where I end is, as a City, we have to be consistent in following the rules that we abide by,” said Mayor Ashcraft. “This is a highly unusual situation that has come to us looking an awful lot like a done deal. And then to have the developer who wants to do this project fund the park master plan just makes it look even more questionable.”

Ashcraft pointed to the City partnering with Neptune to host the May 2025 open house introducing the surf pool concept, the unscientific community survey led by Neptune, not the City, and the artist’s rendering.

Attendees at that open house were asked what they wanted for additional improvements and programs in the park outside the surf pool facility, treating the surf pool as a given. In addition, the City’s website allows residents to subscribe to updates for “Enterprise Park Phase 1 – Surf Park,” which gives the impression a phased master plan has already been approved.

The City did not respond to the Alameda Post’s inquiry as to whether the City shared its email addresses from the notification list with Neptune.

https://img.particlenews.com/image.php?url=3CntnB_1HAj0pf200
Screenshot from the City of Alameda’s email update subscription webpage.

Mayor Ashcraft cautioned the Council against being tempted by getting a park master plan paid for while foreclosing other opportunities. She suggested going back and handling it like any master plan.

Vice-Mayor Michele Pryor, who said she has never visited the site but heard that “it is safe but old,” shared a similar sentiment. “It feels like we skipped a step,” she said. She sought clarification about opening a bidding process for such a project.

City Manager Beaudin then clarified that if a request for proposals (RFP) open bidding process for the project were pursued, there would be selection and performance criteria with a timeline and types of community benefits required. “In this case, Neptune approached the City for this project at this site,” he said. “The City did not prepare a package based on property information and constraints, nor was it part of the City Council’s work plan.” He added that it is something the City has been working through in closed session.

Economic Development Director Abby Thorne-Lyman noted that in a competitive process everyone would be given equal footing. The City would set forth its expectations, and a developer could be required to pay for staff time to prepare the ENA. She also informed the Council that there will be several other sites coming on the market in the commercial district next year.

Beaudin said the Council’s direction would determine whether the project falls under the Recreation and Parks Department or the Economic Development Department.

Council members focused primarily on securing a Neptune-funded park master plan through an ENA. Councilmember Tony Daysog favored preparing an ENA with Neptune because “they are willing to front the cost of a master planning process.” He reasoned that if the process shows that a surf pool facility is not desired in Enterprise Park, then the city “could figure out a process for everyone else,” including considering a surf pool in the commercial district.

Councilmember Tracy Jensen also was pleased that Neptune was willing to make the investment in a City-led park master plan process, even if it doesn’t work out for them. Councilmember Greg Boller wanted to stick with Neptune, saying this process “has been a year-and-a-half in the making,” and an environmental review would be conducted. Councilmember Pryor, who initially favored a competitive bidding process before entering exclusive talks, ultimately supported an ENA with Neptune because the park “is just a big parking lot and a warehouse,” “it is not a final plan,” and “there is no downside for us.”

Ashcraft then pleaded her case again. “I would want to see the process spelled out and would want others to be given the opportunity,” she said. “We have a fiduciary duty. We are stewards of this land. And we have to be open and transparent regardless of who it is.”

The mayor then reminded everyone that, “A new mayor and Council will come forward, and it is incumbent upon us to give them this project in an acceptable manner without bending the rules.”

Councilmember Boller asked Beaudin if an RFP process for a surf pool could happen after the park master plan was completed.

“The idea of [Neptune] paying for the plan and someone else getting the deal could be an interesting set of circumstances,” Beaudin responded. “If we’re looking to solicit interest in a surf pool, we have commercially available properties for that kind of use, and we might approach it differently.”

Beaudin added that “this happens to be public park land close to the water,” and “it would probably not be our first choice. …The City was approached out of the blue, and it included a community planning effort.”

Mayor Ashcraft persevered, asking Council to give direction to explore the commercial district option as well. Councilmember Boller answered that it is unclear if the applicant would be interested in that option, and it is not known whether the City would lose an opportunity for getting a park master plan funded.

Beaudin noted that nothing precludes people from approaching the City during any of these planning processes to purchase property for a surf pool facility. “We don’t need an RFP,” he said. “It would be a traditional real estate transaction. The market is the market.” He added that the City Council would review any City-owned land sales or long-term leases for surf park interests.

“I couldn’t support an ENA. We’ve heard from the public. It doesn’t satisfy the transparency test,” Mayor Ashcraft maintained. “My concerns would be satisfied if we did a master plan and, after that, an ENA.”

In closing, Beaudin drew a distinction between the ENA and the planning process. “We will find a way to create an agreement that allows for a private entity to fund a study for a publicly owned piece of public property,” he said. “An ENA is really about a project. The planning exercise could be a different tool,”

“Precisely,” Ashcraft responded. Otherwise, she said, “it seems like a foregone conclusion.”

Baudin said he will find out if the applicant is amenable to a separate master plan funding agreement.

Contributing writer Irene Dieter’s articles are collected at alamedapost.com/Irene-Dieter, and she posts stories and photos about Alameda to her site, I on Alameda.

The post Analysis: Mayor, Council Spar Over Surf Pool Process appeared first on Alameda Post.

emoji_wow
emoji_like
2

Comments