undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Cobb judge dismisses Acworth murder charges
By Specialhriggall,
2023-06-05A man who was accused of murdering a woman at an Acworth gas station in 2021 acted in self defense, a Cobb County judge ruled.
Superior Court Chief Judge Gregory Poole granted Corbin Scott Engler immunity from criminal prosecution in the death of Katie Lambert in April. Last week, the charges were dismissed after prosecutors elected not to appeal the ruling.
The incident involved three people threatening Engler at the gas station, mistakenly believing he was hurting his child, Poole found. Lambert got onto the hood of Engler’s car as he sped off from the gas station. Lambert fell onto the pavement and received head injuries which she later died from.
Cobb District Attorney Flynn Broady’s office pursued charges of felony murder, aggravated assault and cruelty to children against Engler. But in reviewing the evidence, Poole found that the actions of the three people who threatened Engler, “gave rise to Defendant’s reasonable belief that force was necessary to defend himself and his family.”
“In driving his car to escape the justifiably perceived threat, Defendant did not act with unlawful force. Under the law, the Court finds that Defendant is thereby immune from prosecution,” Poole wrote.
Engler said he was relieved to have the charges dismissed.
“I’m at a loss for words for it, because it’s such a serious crime and I didn’t know how it was going to turn out. But the only praise I can give is to God, because it was all in his hands,” Engler told the MDJ.
Fatal mistake
According to Judge Poole’s order, Engler, his wife Emiley, his mother-in-law and two of his children had gone out to dinner on the night of Jan. 2, 2021. On the way home, the family stopped at a Valero gas station on Main Street in Acworth.
One child rode with Engler’s mother-in-law, while his 3-year-old boy, rode with Engler and his wife. At the gas station, Engler’s wife went inside while Engler and his son stayed in the car, Poole wrote. Engler’s mother-in-law and other child were in the car parked next to his.
The son, upset he could not go inside with his mother, unbuckled himself and exited the car, before his mother told him to get back in the car, Poole wrote. The son got back in the car, and Engler buckled the child back into his car seat.
When Emiley exited the gas station and got back in the car, two men — Quentin DeVille and Thomas Russell — approached the driver’s side door. DeVille and Russell confronted Engler. Russell later told police he told Engler to leave before they called 911 on him.
As an alarmed Engler backed out of the parking spot, the men continued to approach the passenger side of the vehicle, while Katie Lambert of White, Georgia, DeVille’s girlfriend, blocked the vehicle, Poole wrote. Lambert got onto the hood as DeVille used a pocket knife to shatter Engler’s windshield.
Engler accelerated and drove off, causing Lambert to fall and injure her head. She died from her injuries in February of this year.
Despite the state theorizing that Engler and his wife were arguing, Poole found that was not the case. The judge also found that prosecutors “through no direct evidence at all, insinuated … that the defendant and/or his wife were intoxicated to some extent.”
As to claims from DeVille and prosecutors that Engler struck his child, Poole noted that police examined the child and found no evidence that he had been injured. The evidence, the judge wrote, corroborates Engler’s claim that he was simply buckling his child back into the car seat.
“There is no evidence before the Court that Defendant used force in an unlawful or unauthorized manner,” Poole wrote. “The Court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that Defendant had a reasonable belief that there was an imminent threat of violence against himself and his family and that his car was his only means of escaping that violence.”
Broady’s office filed a motion asking Poole to reconsider his order, which he denied. Broady’s office elected not to appeal the order, so the charges were dismissed last week.
Reached for comment, Broady’s office was still working on a statement as of press time.
‘They had it all wrong’
Engler had bonded out after his initial arrest. When Katie Lambert died, he was charged with murder and had to turn himself back in.
While in jail for the second time, Engler's family lost their apartment due to him being unable to work for more than a month. Engler said he was grateful to his employer, who held his position for him.
Engler, 28, lives in Paulding County and works for a company that bores tunnels for sewers and utilities.
“It was scary, because I’d just had a baby,” Engler said. “… I didn’t know if that was the last time I was going to see my child for however many years, the last time I was going to see my wife or any of my family, for that matter. It was a very scary situation.”
The whole event transpired in less than 45 seconds, Engler said. The events changed his outlook — he values life more, but he’s also stopped speaking to strangers in public.
“It was a horrible tragic situation … Somebody lost their life out of this situation, it’s very hard to deal with,” Engler said.
Engler was represented by attorney Megan Grout.
“The police jumped to conclusions, all this negative stuff came out about him and his family, there was a picture of him, his wife and her son on the internet,” Grout said. “And in the end, they had it all wrong.”
Marietta attorney Maddox Kilgore has practiced law for 30 years, first as a prosecutor before switching to criminal defense. He’s never worked on a case where a judge granted immunity from prosecution, and said it’s a high legal bar for a defendant to clear.
“Once I heard about it I was like ... you got to be kidding me,’” Kilgore said. “I mean, it’s a big deal.”
Grout, an attorney of more than 25 years, has only had one other case where a murder charge was dismissed and ruled self-defense. And this was the only case where all the charges were thrown out.
“He did what we would’ve wanted him to do,” Grout said. “He tried to get away from a bad situation.”