undefined
Posts
undefined
Followers
Blaine approves franchise fee implementations
By Elliot Steeves,
1 days agoBlaine plans to begin collecting new fees on gas and electric service in 2027 to help pay for street work after the City Council approved five franchise fees Nov. 16.
The council voted 4-2, with Council Members Chris Massoglia and Jess Robertson opposed.
Finance Director Jason Zimmerman said the city held seven workshops beginning in January 2025 to look for revenue sources that could reduce its reliance on recurring property tax increases. The city used Blaine customer data to project revenue from the fees and adopted ordinances governing the utility agreements Oct. 19.
Zimmerman said the city’s goal was to avoid placing a disproportionate burden on property owners. Under the proposed fee structure residential and commercial property owners would pay less than they would if the city raised the same amount through its property tax levy.
The council has discussed using the revenue for infrastructure, particularly pavement management. It would retain control over how the money is spent and could make that decision each year through the budget process. The city intends to collect the fees in 2027 and incorporate the revenue into its 2028 budget.
City Manager Erik Thorvig said council members had also discussed adopting a formal policy governing how the money could be spent and what votes would be required.
“We have policies around other funds like this that we have, and so if this is adopted this evening, staff would propose to create a draft policy and have it be brought before workshop and have it be adopted sometime before 2028 when we would anticipate using these funds,” Thorvig said.
Council Member Tom Newland supported the fees. He said he has advocated for diversifying the city’s revenue since joining the council four and a half years ago.
“We have very limited options to bring in additional revenue streams, this is one of them,” Newland said. “We will also be looking at others, and this is the easiest one for us to implement in a relatively short time frame, after talking about it for quite some time.”
Newland said the fees would help the city pay for its increasingly expensive road replacement and mill-and-overlay programs while continuing to rebuild streets. He also pointed to the cost of borrowing for past projects.
“And with the number of bonds that we have going back a number of years, I want to say the total is 16, 17 some bonds, and the interest payments that we are making every year are in the millions of dollars,” Newland said.
He said the revenue could also help cover other city expenses and development.
Massoglia said his concern was less about how the city pays for services than how much it spends overall.
“I think until we address, big picture, the amount of money we’re spending…I do not support additional fees,” Massoglia said.
Council Member Leslie Larson said a comparison of cities showed Blaine and Maple Grove without alternative revenue sources beyond property taxes.
“We are solely relying on our property taxes for our funding of the city,” Larson said. “We have to spread it out a little bit. We have to have other ways that other entities participate, so it’s not just on the property taxes.”
Larson also said the National Sports Center and the airport do not generate revenue for Blaine because they are state-owned, adding to the need for another revenue source.
A franchise agreement sets the terms under which a utility constructs, operates and maintains equipment in public rights of way. It can also address tree trimming and road restoration after utility work. Cities can require permits for work in those rights of way.
A city can charge a gas or electric utility a franchise fee for using public rights of way. An ordinance establishes the fee’s structure, collection schedule and effective date. Blaine has not previously collected gas or electric franchise fees.
Zimmerman said staff has met with all the providers and that agreements with each are needed to establish the fees.
He listed several advantages: The fees would reach a broader customer base than property taxes, including customers at tax-exempt properties; provide a steady revenue stream under local control; and allow new construction to contribute immediately, rather than after the one- to two-year lag before the city receives property taxes. He also listed no administration costs as an advantage.
The drawbacks, Zimmerman said, include the fact that customers pay for essential gas and electric service, unlike cable subscribers who can choose whether to pay cable franchise fees. Establishing the fees with all providers would also take significant administrative time, and providers could resist implementing them.
Utilities can establish different customer classifications, allowing fees to reflect differences in infrastructure demands and usage. Blaine used Lakeville’s recently adopted flat-rate fees as a model because Zimmerman said it is a comparable city and its rates reflect current conditions. He said Lakeville’s approach provides predictable revenue for budgeting without placing the cost on one customer classification. According to Zimmerman, Lakeville’s pavement management capital improvement plan has an average annual funding gap of more than $5 million.